Speaking at the
Davos World Economic Forum, US Climate Envoy John Kerry offered a strong
critique of natural gas: “Gas is primarily methane, and we have a huge
methane problem, folks.”
Kerry was responding to Shell CEO Ben van
Breundel’s argument that the US government should reduce demand for
fossil fuels and not take action to reduce production by companies like
Shell.
UN Deputy Secretary General Amina Mohammed offered an even more blunt
criticism of van Breundel’s argument that we can drill our way out of
global warming: “You can’t be talking about new [fossil-fuel
exploration and production], when the science tells you have to reduce
that production 6 percent per annum and you’re increasing by 2 percent.”
Remarks by U.S. Special Presidential Envoy for Climate, John Kerry at
the opening of the Climate Adaptation Summit 2021.
Transcript:
It’s a privilege to be able to be with you. And let me start by
thanking Prime Minister Rutte and the government of the Netherlands
for hosting this important and timely meeting.
I’m really delighted to be here. I also want to thank, if I may,
Secretary General Guterres for his tireless leadership on climate
change. And of course my friend Ban Ki-Moon, who was central as we
negotiated the Paris agreement and brought it into force. And he’s
been a partner not just on climate but on many other things and
challenges.
Three years ago, scientists gave us a pretty stark warning. They said
we have 12 years within which to avoid the worst consequences of
climate change. Now we have nine years left. And I regret that my
country has been absent for three of those years.
In the United States, we spent 265 billion dollars in one year for
three storms, just cleaning up after those storms. Last year, one
storm, 55 billion dollars.
We’ve reached the point where it is an absolute fact that it’s cheaper
to invest in preventing damage, or minimizing it at least, than
cleaning up. Now, without question, I think, everybody understands
this, the best adaptation is to treat the crisis as the emergency that
it is and do more to hold the earth’s temperature increase to the
Paris-stated 1.5 degrees. I think scientists are more and more landing
on the 1.5 as a critical figure.
A 3.7 to 4.5 increase centigrade, which is
exactly the path that we are on now, invites for the most vulnerable
and poorest people on earth fundamentally unlivable conditions. So our
urgent reduction of emissions is compelled by public conscience and by
common sense. President Biden has made fighting climate change a top
priority of his administration. We have a president now, thank God,
who leads, tells the truth, and is seized by this issue.
And President Biden knows that we have to mobilize in unprecedented
ways to meet a challenge that is fast accelerating. And he knows we
have limited time to get it under control. For that reason, the United
States immediately rejoined the Paris agreement. And we intend to do
everything we possibly can to ensure that
COP26 results in ambitious climate action,
in which all major-emitter countries raise ambitions significantly,
and in which we help protect those who are the most vulnerable.
We have already launched our work to prepare a new U.S. nationally
determined
contribution
that meets the urgency of the challenge. And we aim to announce our
NDC as soon as practicable.
The administration also intends to make significant investments in
climate action, both domestically and as part of our efforts to build
back better from
COVID. And internationally, we intend to
make good on our climate finance pledge.
In the long term driving towards net zero emissions no later than
2050, and keeping a 1.5 degree limit within reach remain the best
policies for climate resilience and adaptation. There is simply no
adapting to a three or four degree world except for the very richest
and most privileged. At the same time, we have to also build
resilience to protect communities from the impacts of climate change
that already built in to the emissions that are in the atmosphere.
Now some of these impacts are inevitable, because of the warming
that’s already taken place. But if we don’t act boldly and immediately
by building resilience to climate change, we are likely going to see
dramatic reversals in economic development for everybody. Poor and
climate-vulnerable communities everywhere will obviously pay the
highest price.
So the United States will work on three fronts to promote ambition and
resilience and adaptation: leverage U.S. innovation and climate data
and information to promote a better understanding and management of
climate risk, especially in developed countries; we will significantly
increase the flow of finance, including concessional
finance,
to adaptation and resilience initiatives; we will work with bilateral
and multilateral institutions to improve quality of resilience
programming; and we will work with the private sector, in the United
States and elsewhere in developing countries, to promote greater
collaboration between businesses and the communities on which they
depend.
And it is our firm conviction throughout all of our administration
every agency is now part of our climate team. And only together are we
going to be able to build the resilience to climate change that is
critical to save lives and meet our moral obligation for future
generations, and to those currently living in very difficult
circumstances. So we’re proud to be back. We come back, I want you to
know, with humility, for the absence of the last four years, and we’ll
do everything in our power to make up for it.
The Department of Energy has announced numerous senior
hires,
the vast majority of whom are climate hawks. As with the transition
team,
the picks range from lifelong environmental justice activists to
corporate technologists. Most but not all have previous administration
experience.
Former Michigan governor Jennifer Granholm is the nomineee to be
Secretary of Energy. David G. Huizenga will serve as Acting Secretary of
Energy, and Richard Glick is becoming chair of the Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission.
Energy
Shalanda H. Baker, Deputy Director for Energy Justice. Shalanda H.
Baker was mostly recently a professor of law, public policy, and urban
affairs at Northeastern University. She was the co-founder and
co-director of the Initiative for Energy Justice, which provides
technical law and policy support to communities on the front lines of
climate change. Baker served as an Air Force officer prior to her
honorable discharge pursuant to the then existing “Don’t Ask, Don’t
Tell” policy, and became a vocal advocate for repeal of the policy.
She earned a B.S. in Political Science from the U.S. Air Force
Academy, a J.D. from Northeastern University, and L.L.M. from the
University of Wisconsin.
Robert Cowin, Deputy Assistant Secretary for Public Engagement.
Robert Cowin was most recently director of government affairs for the
Climate & Energy program at the Union of Concerned Scientists. Prior
to that, Cowin worked for the National Environmental Trust, where he
helped organize national campaigns focused on climate change, clean
energy, and clean air. He holds a master’s degree in international
relations from the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts
University, and a B.A. from Boston College.
Tanya Das, Chief of Staff, Office of Science. Tanya Das was most
recently a Professional Staff Member on the U.S. House Committee on
Science, Space, and Technology, where she worked on legislation on a
range of issues in clean energy and manufacturing policy. She was an
AAAS Congressional fellow in the Office of
Senator Chris Coons. She earned her Ph.D. in Electrical Engineering
from the University of California, Santa Barbara, and her B.S. in
Electrical Engineering from the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor.
Christopher Davis, Senior Advisor to the Secretary of Energy.
Christopher Davis served all eight years of the Obama Administration —
first in the White House Office of Legislative Affairs and then in
several senior roles at the Department of Energy. Prior to that, he
worked for the U.S. House Committee on Oversight and Reform and the
U.S. House Committee on Energy and Commerce. More recently, Davis
worked with Co-Equal, a non-profit organization providing expertise
and knowledge to Congress on oversight and legislation.
Ali Douraghy, Chief of Staff, Office of the Under Secretary for
Science & Energy. Ali Douraghy was most recently Chief Strategy
Officer for Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory’s Earth &
Environmental Sciences Area. He led the New Voices program at the
National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine, which brings
diverse leader perspectives into science policy. He received his Ph.D.
in biomedical physics from the UCLA School
of Medicine.
Todd Kim, Deputy General Counsel for Litigation and Enforcement.
Todd Kim most recently was a partner at Reed Smith
LLP, and before that was the first Solicitor
General for the District of Columbia, serving in that capacity more
than 11 years. Kim was an appellate attorney for the U.S. Department
of Justice, Environment and Natural Resources Division, and a clerk on
the D.C. Circuit. Kim graduated magna cum laude from Harvard Law
School, where he was an executive editor of the Harvard Law Review,
and received his undergraduate degree magna cum laude in biology from
Harvard College.
Jennifer Jean Kropke, Director of Energy Jobs. Jennifer Jean
Kropke served as the first Director of Workforce and Environmental
Engagement for IBEW Local Union 11 and the
National Electrical Contractors’ Association-Los Angeles’ Labor
Management Cooperation Committee. She focused on creating clean
energy, port electrification, and zero emission transportation
opportunities for union members. She is a graduate of the
UCLA School of Law.
Andrew Light, Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary for International
Affairs. Andrew Light has worked on international climate and energy
policy in and outside of government for the last 15 years. From 2013
to 2016, he served as Senior Adviser and India Counselor to the U.S.
Special Envoy on Climate Change, as well as a climate adviser in the
Secretary of State’s Office of Policy Planning. Light was an
international climate and energy policy volunteer for the Biden
campaign and was one of the chief architects of Governor Jay Inslee’s
plan for global climate mobilization. He is an environmental
philosopher and is married to Washington Post reporter Juliet
Eilperin. He completed his undergraduate work at Mercer University and
doctoral work at the University of California, Riverside with a
three-year post-doctoral fellowship in environmental risk assessment
at the University of Alberta.
David A. Mayorga, Director of Public Affairs. David A. Mayorga
most recently served as Director of Communications for the Attorney
General for the District of Columbia Karl A. Racine. Previously he was
Senior Spokesperson for the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau and
led communications for DOE’s Solar Energy
Technologies Office, with the SunShot Initiative. He earned a B.A.
from the University of Florida and began his professional career at
the U.S. House Committee on Science.
Shara Mohtadi, Chief of Staff, Office of Energy Efficiency &
Renewable Energy. Shara Mohtadi has focused her career advising
policymakers and international organizations on mitigating climate
change and advancing clean energy policies. She most recently led the
America’s Pledge initiative and managed grants focused on the coal to
clean energy transition in Asia and Australia at Bloomberg
Philanthropies. Previously, Shara served as a senior advisor on
climate and energy policy for New York State government. During the
Obama Administration, Mohtadi served as an advisor for the energy and
environment portfolio at the White House, in the Office of Management
and Budget. She received her undergraduate and graduate degrees from
Columbia University.
Tarak Shah, Chief of Staff. Tarak Shah is an energy policy expert
who has spent the last decade working on combating climate change. At
the Biden-Harris Transition, Shah was the Personnel lead for the
Climate and Science team. From 2014-2017, he served as Chief of Staff
to the Under Secretary for Science and Energy at
DOE. Shah has also worked on political
campaigns, including President Obama’s Senate and presidential
campaigns. He received his undergraduate degree from the University of
Illinois and his M.B.A from Cornell University.
Kelly Speakes-Backman, Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary for
Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy. Kelly Speakes-Backman most
recently served as the first CEO of the
Energy Storage Association, the national trade organization for the
energy storage industry. Speakes-Backman has spent more than 20 years
working in energy and environmental issues in the public,
NGO and private sectors. In 2019, she was
honored by The Cleanie Awards as Woman of the Year.
Narayan Subramanian, Legal Advisor, Office of General Counsel.
Narayan Subramanian was a Visiting Research Fellow at the Center for
Law, Energy, & the Environment at Berkeley Law leading a project
tracking regulatory rollbacks, and served as a Fellow at the
Initiative for Sustainable Energy Policy at Johns Hopkins University
and Data for Progress. He was lead coordinator of the Elizabeth Warren
presidential campaign’s climate and energy policy advisory group.
Subramanian holds a J.D. from Columbia Law School, an M.P.A. from the
School of Public & International Affairs at Princeton University, and
a B.S. in Earth & Environmental Engineering from Columbia University.
Shuchi Talati, Chief of Staff, Office of Fossil Energy. Dr. Shuchi
Talati was most recently a Senior Policy Advisor at Carbon180 where
she focused on policies to build sustainable and equitable
technological carbon removal at scale. She also served as a policy
volunteer on the Biden-Harris campaign. She was a
UCS Fellow on solar geoengineering research
governance and public engagement with the Climate & Energy program at
the Union of Concerned Scientists. Dr. Talati earned a B.S. from
Northwestern University, an M.A. from Columbia University, and a Ph.D.
from Carnegie Mellon University. Her doctoral research focused on the
climate-energy-water nexus looking specifically at the impacts of
domestic climate regulations and carbon capture and storage
technology.
Jennifer Wilcox, Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary for Fossil
Energy. Jennifer Wilcox is a direct carbon air capture
expert.
She was most recently the Presidential Distinguished Professor of
Chemical Engineering and Energy Policy at the University of
Pennsylvania, and a Senior Fellow at the World Resources Institute.
Wilcox’s work examines the nexus of energy and the environment,
developing strategies to minimize negative climate impacts associated
with society’s dependence on fossil fuels. Wilcox holds a Ph.D. in
Chemical Engineering and M.A. in Chemistry from the University of
Arizona and B.A. in Mathematics from Wellesley College.
Avi Zevin, Deputy General Counsel for Energy Policy. Avi Zevin is
an attorney with experience advancing policies that enable the
provision of carbon-free, reliable, and cost-effective electricity.
Until joining the administration, he was energy policy counsel for
Google. He was a senior attorney and Affiliated Scholar at the
Institute for Policy Integrity at New York University School of Law
and an attorney at Van Ness Feldman LLP. He
was a policy advisor for the corporate-funded Third Way think tank
from 2008 to 2009. Zevin holds a J.D., magna cum laude, from New York
University School of Law, an M.P.A. from the Harvard Kennedy School of
Government, and a B.A., with high honors, from the University of
California, Berkeley.
Additional hires without significant reputation as climate policy
experts or advocates include:
Vanessa Z. Chan, Director, Office of Technology Transitions (Chief
Commercialization Officer). Vanessa Z. Chan comes to the
Biden-Harris Administration from the University of Pennsylvania where
she was the Brassington Professor of Practice and the Undergraduate
Chair of the Materials Science and Engineering Department. She has
spent the past 20 years helping large companies commercialize their
technologies and revamping the academic curriculum of engineering
students to make a greater social impact. Dr. Chan is a former
longtime McKinsey & Company partner. She is a Venture Board Director
for Vanguard and United Technology Corporation and a board member at
multiple start-ups. Dr. Chan was the first woman and the first East
Asian elected partner in McKinsey’s North American Chemicals practice.
She is married to Mark van der Helm, the head of Energy, Waste and
Facilities Maintenance at Walmart. Chan earned her Ph.D. in Materials
Science and Engineering from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology
and a B.S. in Engineering from the University of Pennsylvania.
Caroline Grey, White House Liaison. Caroline Grey worked for Biden
for President as Expansion States Director, managing distributed
engagement in 33 states. Previously, she worked on the presidential
campaign of Senator Elizabeth Warren. Grey started her career as an
organizer for then-Senator Barack Obama’s 2008 presidential campaign
and worked on the 2012 Obama re-election campaign. She co-founded
Civis Analytics, a data science firm.
Ali Nouri, Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary for Congressional
and Intergovernmental Affairs. Ali Nouri is a molecular biologist
and most recently was the President of the Federation of American
Scientists, which addresses global health and security risks. In the
past year, he has been working aggressively to fight
COVID-19 misinformation. Prior to that, he
served as a U.S. Senate staffer for a decade for Sens. Jim Webb and Al
Franken and served as an advisor in the office of then UN Secretary
General Kofi Annan. Nouri obtained a B.A. in biology from Reed College
and received his Ph.D. from Princeton University.
This post is an expanded version of a Twitter thread.
With
the pair of Democratic U.S. Senate victories in Georgia, the Democratic
Party will have control of the White House and both chambers of Congress
come January 20th. West Virginia’s Democratic senator, Joe Manchin, will
become the chair of the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, and
will hold tremendous power over any climate legislation.
While I’m sure that part of bribing Manchin to go along with a series of
climate bills as bold as President-elect Joe Biden’s campaign platform
will require funds for coal-industry
boondoggles
like direct air capture and carbon-capture sequestration, as well as for
advanced nuclear
technology,
we ought to be a bit more creative than
that.
Here are a few other ideas to consider:
New funds for building pumped hydroelectric storage facilities in
Appalachia. These use abandoned coal mines to create a low-tech
battery for renewable energy storage, pumping water into the uphill
mines when production is high and releasing it through turbines when
it wanes.
Ending the federal grant program that incentivizes converting
abandoned strip mines into federal prisons. Those funds should go
toward building up the clean
energy
and electrovoltaic manufacturing facilities in Appalachia on sites
that have already been cleared or flattened sites that are adjacent to
transportation infrastructure.
Decommissioning the network of prisons in Appalachia, converting
their onsite and resilient electricity generation
infrastructure
into community-based electric co-ops. Every prison there has the
ability to island itself off from the grid and power itself. Give that
power to the people of Appalachia.
Investing in the now-closed north-south railway that could connect
Appalachia to Atlanta in the South, Pittsburgh to the North, Columbus
and St. Louis to the West, and the entire northeast corridor to the
East. A massive corridor already exists and just needs track upgrades
for it to be active.
Offering Appalachia up as the first pilot site for a new Climate
Conservation Corps that puts people to work capping orphaned wells,
remediating brownfield and other toxic sites, and reforesting the
hiking, hunting, and other recreational landscapes of the region.
The best part of it all is that “bribing” Joe Manchin to go along with a
more progressive climate agenda is really just a way of driving
investment to some of the people and places that need it most—in this
case, Central Appalachia.
Billy Fleming is the Wilks Family Director of the Ian L. McHarg Center
in the Weitzman School of Design. and a senior fellow with Data for
Progress.
Even
though the loser of the presidential election, Donald Trump, continues
his quest for autogolpe, President-elect Joe Biden’s transition team is
hard at work preparing his new administration. Among the hundreds of
staff and volunteers comprising the agency review
teams
are dozens of climate hawks. These are people with significant
experience in climate policy and politics. Some have careers rooted in
environmental justice, while others are technologists.
Cabinet departments are listed in order of creation, an approximate
reflection of their power and significance within the federal
government. This post will be continually updated.
State (nominee: Tony Blinken)
Susan Biniaz, the lead climate lawyer and climate negotiator in
the State Department from 1989 to 2017, and was central to the
drafting of the Paris agreement. She is presently a senior fellow at
the UN
Foundation
and lectures on international climate negotiations at
Yale (her alma mater) and
Columbia
University (from
which she received her law degree).
Andy Green, a U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission lawyer from
2014 to 2015 and a longtime counsel for U.S. Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-OR),
worked on pricing climate risk while at the
SEC. As a Center for American Progress
fellow, he has been an outspoken advocate for ending the financing of
carbon
polluters.
Marisa Lago, former Assistant Secretary for International Markets
and Development, has experience with international climate
finance
as well as urban climate adaptation
planning.
Lago is presently the director of city planning for New York City,
having held similar roles in the 1990s for Boston and New York City.
Before joining the Obama administration, Lago was Global Head of
Compliance for Citigroup after a similar role at the S.E.C. running
the Office of International Affairs.
Prominent environmental law scholar Richard Lazarus, a Harvard Law
professor. His most recent book, The Law of Five, reviews the
landmark Massachusetts v. EPA Supreme Court case which affirmed that
greenhouse emissions are pollution. He served as the executive
director of the National Commission on the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil
Spill and Future of Offshore Drilling. In 1992, he was part of
Clinton’s transition team for the Environment and Natural Resources
Division of the U.S. Department of Justice. In a recent
interview,
he stated, “There’s no greater problem that overwhelms us these days
in environmental law than climate change.”
Interior (nominee: Rep. Deb Haaland (D-N.M.))
Maggie Thomas is the political director at Evergreen
Action, a
climate advocacy group run by veterans of Jay Inslee’s presidential
campaign. Thomas was climate policy advisor for the Elizabeth Warren
campaign after Inslee’s campaign ended, where she was deputy climate
director. She joined Inslee’s campaign from Tom Steyer’s NextGen
America organization. She holds a B.S. in biology and environmental
management from Trinity College and a masters in environmental
management from the Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies.
Kate Kelly served in the Obama administration as senior adviser to
and communications director for Secretary of the Interior Sally
Jewell. She is the director of public lands at the Center for American
Progress. Previously, she was communications director for Sen. Arlen
Spector (R-Penn.) She has written on how the United States can
equitably abandon fossil-fuel
extraction
and embrace renewable energy development on public
lands.
Elizabeth Johnson Klein, an environmental attorney and former
Deputy Assistant Secretary at
Interior for
Policy, Management & Budget during the Obama administration and served
as assistant to the Secretary of the Interior in the Clinton
administration. Klein is now the Deputy Director of the State Energy
& Environmental Impact
Center
at NYU School of Law. For years she worked
with Obama and Clinton Interior official David Hayes, the center’s
director. She received her B.A. in economics from George Washington
University and her JD from American University, where she was
president of the Environmental Law Society. She has written on
environmental
justice
and the dire need for climate
leadership.
Team lead Robert Bonnie, former U.S.D.A. Under Secretary for
Natural Resources and Environment and Senior Advisor to Secretary of
Agriculture Tom Vilsack for environment and climate change, is the
co-author of the Climate 21 Project’s U.S.D.A.
chapter, which lays out a comprehensive
climate
agenda
for the agency. Now a scholar at Duke University’s environmental
policy
institute,
Bonnie was formerly the vice president for land conservation for the
Environmental Defense Fund. He has a master’s in environmental
management from Duke and a B.A. from Harvard.
Meryl Harrell, now the executive
director at
Southern Appalachian Wilderness Stewards, worked for Bonnie at the
U.S.D.A. and was his co-author on the Climate 21 Project chapter. She
has a B.A. in geoscience and environmental studies from Princeton and
a J.D. from Yale Law School.
Jonathan Coppess, former chief counsel for the Senate Agriculture
Committee
and administrator of the U.S.D.A. Farm Service Agency, has worked on
biofuels programs including the Renewable Fuels Standard and biomass
crops as well as several land, water, and soil conservation programs
for farmers.
Andrea Delgado is a co-founder of Green
Latinos, a
national Latino environmental justice organization. Currently the
chief lobbyist for the United Farm Workers Foundation, she was
previously legislative director of the Healthy Communities program at
Earthjustice.
John Padalino is the former administrator for
USDA’s Rural Utilities
Service, having also
served as Chief of Staff to the Under Secretary for Rural Development
to Acting Principal Deputy General Counsel in the department. He works
on rural water and electric cooperatives and is now general counsel to
Bandera Electric Cooperative, a rural Texas electricity provider that
has been working on smart grids and solar deployment for its members.
Jeffrey Prieto is a long-time Department of Justice environmental
lawyer who helped
set up its environmental justice division. He rose to general counsel
at USDA during the Obama administration. He
is presently general counsel for the Los Angeles Community College
District.
Commerce
Karen Hyun, Ph.D. is the former Deputy Assistant Secretary for
Fish and Wildlife and Parks at the Department of the Interior and was
Interior Secretary John Bryson’s senior policy adviser on energy and
environment
issues.
She is now Vice President for Coastal
Conservation at the
National Audubon Society. She has a Ph.D. in Marine Affairs at the
University of Rhode Island M.S. and B.S. in Earth Systems from
Stanford University.
Kathryn Sullivan, Ph.D., former NOAA
administrator.
Both an oceanographer and astronaut, she is the only human to have
both walked in space and visited the Challenger Deep. She served as
NOAA’s chief scientist during the Clinton
administration. She received her bachelor’s in earth sciences from
U.C. Santa Cruz and her Ph.D. in geology from Dalhousie University.
She has written on the urgency of the climate
crisis
and fought
attempts
by climate denier Rep. Lamar Smith (R-Texas) to hobble her agency.
Political scientist Todd Tucker, director of governance studies at
the Roosevelt Institute, author of The Green New Deal: A Ten-Year
Window to Reshape International Economic
Law.
Tucker has a bachelor’s degree from George Washington University and a
PhD from the University of Cambridge. He was the long time research
director at Public Citizen.
Kris Sarri, President and
CEO,
National Marine Sanctuary Foundation.
She was a climate and oceans Senate staffer with Sen. Jack Reed
(D-R.I.) from 2006 to 2010, and worked in the Obama administration as
chief climate and oceans staff in the Commerce Department, and rose to
senior positions at the Office of Management and Budget and Interior.
An Ann Arbor native, she received her MS and
MPH from the University of Michigan and BA
from Washington University in St Louis.
Dr. Sandra Whitehouse,
oceanographer and
marine policy expert who has studied the impacts of climate change on
our oceans. She is a
senior policy advisor for the Nature Conservancy and the wife of Sen.
Sheldon Whitehouse
(D-R.I.). Dr. Whitehouse holds a B.S. from Yale University and a Ph.D.
in biological oceanography from the Graduate School of Oceanography at
the University of Rhode Island. As her husband has done on the Senate
floor, Dr. Whitehouse has raised the alarm about the crisis of
climate
pollution.
“We are just beginning to understand the far-reaching impacts
temperature change is having on ecosystems and wildlife. We are seeing
the entire collapse of deep-sea ecosystems, and we don’t know what
those ramifications are.”
Labor
Josh Orton, senior policy advisor to climate champion Sen. Bernie
Sanders (I-Vt.). As Orton
said
when Sanders unveiled his climate plan during his presidential
campaign, “This threat is beyond ideology — it’s a question of life
and death.”
Health and Human Servicesnone
Housing and Urban Developmentnone
Transportation
Patty Monahan, lead commissioner on transportation for the
California Energy
Commission.
Monahan has worked on clean transportation policy and
advocacy for the Energy
Foundation, the Union of Concerned Scientists, the Environmental
Protection Agency, and Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory. She
received a B.S. in environmental studies from U.C. Berkeley and an
M.S. from the Energy Analysis and Policy program of the University of
Wisconsin. Monahan: “Climate Change was and remains the single biggest
problem facing our world and energy is a major piece of the puzzle.”
Dr. Austin Brown, executive
director
of the UC Davis Policy Institute for Energy, the Environment, and the
Economy. Brown was the Assistant Director for Clean Energy and
Transportation in the Obama White House’s Office of Science and
Technology Policy. He has also
worked in the Department of
Energy and the National Renewable Energy Laboratory. He holds a B.S.
in physics from Harvey Mudd College and a Ph.D. in biophysics from
Stanford University. He is working towards a
zero-carbon
transportation sector.
President-elect
Joe Biden has named former senator and Secretary of State John Kerry as
his special envoy for climate, sitting on the National Security Council.
Throughout his long career of public service, Kerry has been an ardent
environmentalist who seeks to find common ground through diplomacy. His
approach has found greater success on the international stage than with
American conservatives, despite repeated attempts.
As a Massachusetts senator, Kerry worked desperately to salvage climate
legislation when it was abandoned by the Obama White House following the
Tea Party uprising of 2009. Lacking a unified Democratic caucus, Kerry
tried without success to find Republican votes for climate legislation
by working with former running mate Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-Conn.) and
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.).
As Obama’s second Secretary of State, John Kerry’s diplomatic leadership
was key to the successful Paris agreement, which marked a dramatic
turnaround from the 2009 debacle of the Copenhagen climate talks. His
support for killing the Canada-to-US Keystone XL tar-sands pipeline – in
response to powerful pressure from climate activists – was also a change
in direction from Kerry’s predecessor Hillary Clinton, who fast-tracked
the permit process for the project. Like
Clinton,
however, Secretary of State Kerry was bullish on
fracking
as a means of energy diplomacy, despite its threat to the climate.
Kerry’s diplomatic approach has borne less fruit at home. Republicans
such as Newt
Gingrich
and Donald
Trump
mocked Secretary Kerry for calling global warming “perhaps the world’s
most fearsome weapon of mass destruction,” presaging the
burn-it-all-down Trump presidency.
During the Trump years, Kerry founded a new organization called World
War Zero, still attempting to find
Republicans to
get on board with climate action. Although Kerry’s organization
supposedly intends to build a broad coalition of climate activists,
World War Zero’s Republican participants include climate-science skeptic
John Kasich, who mocks youth climate
activists and
vilifies the Green New
Deal.
In his role Kerry will face several challenges unresolved by previous
administrations. To date, immigration, trade, peace, and climate policy
have been treated as wholly distinct milieus by government and advocates
alike. Remarkably, even energy and climate diplomacy have largely
operated on parallel tracks, with clashing agendas.
A critical test will be whether Kerry has say over international trade
agreements which have always trumped climate negotiations. The so-called
free-trade agenda has rendered international climate deals moot.
Similarly, it remains to be seen if Kerry will be an effective spokesman
for the global South as it is ravaged by fossil-fueled storms and floods
and drought, destabilizing governments and fueling the global migration
crisis.
The military euphemism is that climate pollution is a “threat
multiplier” – in other words, global conflict is now defined by the
devastation to human civilization that results from the industrial
destabilization of a habitable climate.
In response to this rising destabilization, right-wing movements around
the globe have seized on the politics of militarized nativism and
environmental exploitation, described approvingly by white-nationalist
ecologist Garrett Hardin as “lifeboat
ethics”
in 1974.
One hopes that Kerry’s position on the National Security Council could
mean the US military may shift away from its longtime role as the armed
protection for the global oil industry. Kerry is highly interested in
the military’s role during the Anthropocene. With his World War Zero
campaign, Kerry has brought together a long list of military brass and
former Defense Department officials.
Unfortunately, the primary narrative for climate policy within military
circles is one of responding to the rising threats of climate
destruction, with little to no engagement in ending climate pollution.
Of course, Kerry can’t guide international climate policy on his own.
The makeup of Biden’s team will determine what is possible.
Biden campaign advisor Heather Zichal, who has become
notorious
for joining the fracked-gas industry after leaving the Obama White
House, came to
prominence
as the top Kerry climate policy staffer on his presidential campaign and
in his Senate office. Zichal has been mentioned as a possible high-level
staffer in the Biden White House despite broad opposition from climate
activists.
Biden’s pick for Secretary of State, Antony Blinken, began his career
studying fossil-fuel geopolitics. He wrote his
dissertation
in the 1980s on the Siberian pipeline
crisis,
in which the Reagan administration imposed far-reaching sanctions on
oil-sector technology sharing in an attempt to block the pipeline’s
construction. Blinken criticized the sanctions effort. His career since
has been
interventionist
and pro-fossil-fuel
development.
Surmounting the challenges of being Biden’s international climate czar
will be a life-defining test for the 76-year-old statesman.
The youth-led
Sunrise Movement and progressive political group Justice Democrats have
teamed up for the Climate Mandate
campaign to push President-elect Biden to assemble a progressive
governing team. Their message:
“President-elect Joe Biden defeated Donald Trump with the highest youth
turnout ever. Now, Joe Biden must assemble a powerful governing team to
stop the climate crisis, create millions of good-paying jobs, address
systemic racism, and control the COVID-19
pandemic.”
The “Climate Cabinet” should have no ties to fossil fuel companies, or
corporate lobbyists; be representative of America; and “fight with the
urgency that the climate crisis demands,” the groups say.
In addition, they are calling for the formation of the White House
Office of Climate Mobilization to coordinate efforts across agencies.
They offer three recommendations each for many Cabinet-level agencies,
with a top pick listed first. The list leans heavily into the
progressive caucus of the House of Representatives, not surprisingly
previously endorsed for election by the groups. The list does not
include some major departments, like Defense and Energy. Some of their
recommendations, like Rep. Deb Haaland (D-N.M.) for Interior, Sen.
Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) for Treasury, and Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.)
for Labor, are known to be on Biden’s short list of
candidates.
People can support the effort by signing a
petition for a “fierce and creative
governing team” to “build back better from the crises we’re in.”
In an aggressive video promoting the effort, the groups ask of Biden:
“Will he be the leader of the American majority, or will he be Mitch
McConnell’s vice president?”
“Climate Crisis: Can We Dial It
Down?,”
the November cover issue of the magazine sent to all of Harvard
University’s thousands of alumni, is yet another in a long
line
of climate-change think pieces by white men interviewing other white
men.
(Understandably, all of the interviewees are professors or alumni of
Harvard University.)
The piece, written by managing editor Jonathan Shaw ‘89, hits the
traditional technocratic notes with such an approach – a physics-heavy
understanding of the enormity of the global
crisis,
some trenchant words from Bill McKibben questioning neoliberalism, and
then several pages of discussion of the potential deployment of new
technology, from electric vehicles to direct air capture and solar
geoengineering (blotting out the sun with stratospheric pollution to
cool the earth).
Nine of the ten interviewees are white men:
Dan Schrag, director of the Harvard University Center for the
Environment
Bill McKibben, Harvard ’82, journalist and climate activist
James Stock, professor of political economy
Richard Zeckhauser, professor of political economy
Joseph Aldy, professor of the practice of public policy
David Keith, professor of public policy and applied physics
Peter Huybers, a professor of earth and planetary sciences and of
environmental science and engineering
Raymond Pierrehumbert, Harvard ’76, professor of physics at Oxford
Frank Keutsch, professor of engineering and atmospheric science
The tenth, Katharine Mach, Harvard ’04, an associate professor at the
University of Miami School of Marine and Atmospheric Science, provides a
voice of caution about geoengineering.
Shaw gives the last word to Schrag’s perspective that the catastrophe of
man-made global warming may compel the catastrophe of deliberate
man-made global cooling. This hubristic logic of destructive escalation
has of course led to great tragedy throughout human history. Harvard’s
role in one such disaster, the Vietnam War, was detailed in David
Halberstam’s “The Best and the
Brightest.”
Shaw was not able to incorporate a section on climate
refugees
into the cover article; the piece appears as a sidebar in the printed
magazine. It features his other female interviewee, Jennifer Leaning,
professor of the practice of health and human rights at the Harvard T.H.
Chan School of Public Health, and associate professor of emergency
medicine at Harvard Medical School.
The nine men interviewed are highly intelligent and accomplished men who
have dedicated their lives to understanding and combatting the climate
crisis. But like all people they do so within the constraints of their
skills, experiences, and social position; their numerous commonalities
(including those with the author of the piece) lead to a stunted vision
of what is at stake and what can be done, let alone what should be done,
about the poisoning of our climate system for the profit and power of
the few.
An intentional corrective to this bias and limited perspective can be
found in the newly published All We Can Save, an anthology of climate
essays and poems by 50 racially and geographically diverse women,
co-edited by Dr. Ayana Elizabeth Johnson, Harvard ‘02.
Speaking
on the Pod Save America show, Democratic presidential nominee Joe Biden
explained that acting on climate change is his top priority and why he
doesn’t expect another fossil-fueled electricity plant to be built in
the United States.
Biden told hosts Dan Pfeiffer and Jon Lovett, both former Obama White
House staff, “It’s the number one issue facing humanity. And it’s the
number one issue for me.”
“It’s becoming a fait accompli,” Biden continued, “No one’s going to
build another oil or gas-fired electric plant. They’re going to build
one that is fired by renewable energy.”
In the interview, Biden went on to claim that in the 1980s he was “the
first person ever to lay out the need to deal with global warming,” and
that Politifact said “it was a game changer.” This bit of puffery refers
to his successful introduction in 1987 of the Global Climate Protection
Act, amending Rep. George Brown (D-Calif.)’s 1978 Global Climate Program
Act (15 USC Chapter 56) to explicitly discuss
manmade global
warming
as a U.S. policy priority.
Biden was far from the first in the world (or in the U.S. Congress) to
call attention to the greenhouse effect, however. Scientists raised the
specter of global warming in congressional testimony in the 1950s and
1960s, and the Clean Air Act of 1970 explicitly mentioned climate
pollution. Hearings for Rep. Brown’s legislation began in 1976.
Politifact has
confirmed
Biden’s considerably less grandiose claim that he was “one of the first
guys to introduce a climate change bill,” which is entirely accurate.
However, Politifact did
not
call his bill a “game changer,” a false claim Biden has
repeatedlymade.
Rather, they cited Josh Howe, a professor of history and environmental
studies at Reed College, who said it was “important not to overstate the
impact of Biden’s bill.”
Consistent with the campaign spots, Biden explained why he believes “we
have a moral obligation to everyone” to act on climate change:
Look what’s happening right now. You just look around the United
States of America. Forests are burning at a rate larger than
Connecticut and Rhode Island combined being lost. People are losing
their homes, their lives. In the middle of the country, we’re in a
situation where you have 100-year floods occurring every several years
wiping out entire, entire counties, and doing great damage.
He argued that the United States makes up “15 [percent] of the
problem” and other countries are responsible for the rest. (The United
States is actually responsible for about 25
percent of
cumulative climate pollution.)
Calling it “bizarre” that everyone doesn’t recognize the economic
potential of climate action, Biden noted that “the fastest growing
industries are solar and wind.” This remarkable claim is essentially
correct: solar panel installers and wind turbine
technicians share the top
three spots with nurse practitioners as the fastest growing professions
in the United States.
Biden noted these jobs are “not paying 15 bucks an hour, they’re paying
prevailing wage.” He did overstate the quality of these jobs, saying
they pay “45 to 50 bucks an hour, plus benefits,” or a $90,000 annual
salary. The actual median wage of solar installers and wind technicians
is closer to $50,000, which is still considerably more than a
$15-an-hour ($30,000 annual) salary.
The only major statewide initiatives are in Alaska and Louisiana, both
of which have ballot measures to increase oil drilling taxes.
Here is a review of climate and energy initiatives, measures, and state
constitution amendments on the ballot this November 3, drawn from
Ballotpedia and
Earther’s Dharna
Noor:
Statewide
Initiative: The campaign Vote Yes for Alaska’s Fair
Share proposed the ballot initiative to
increase taxes on oil production fields located in Alaska’s North Slope
that exceeded certain output minimums. According to Robin Brena,
chairperson of Vote Yes for Alaska’s Fair Share, three oil production
fields—Alpine, Kuparuk, and Prudhoe Bay—met those criteria. BP ($4.54
million), Conoco Phillips ($4.70 million), Hilcorp Energy ($4.3
million), and ExxonMobil ($3.74 million) are funding the campaign to
defeat Measure 1.
California Proposition 15, the Tax on Commercial and Industrial
Properties for Education and Local Government Funding Initiative,
would require commercial and industrial properties, except those zoned
as commercial agriculture, to be taxed based on their market value,
rather than their purchase price, overturning part of 1978’s Proposition
13.
“Oil and gas companies are among the biggest forces lobbying against
this measure because they could stand to lose out on a lot of money if
it passes,” according to Noor. For example, Contra Costa County, the
home of Chevron’s oil refinery in Richmond, would gain about $400
million a
year
in property taxes.
Opponents are falsely
claiming
Prop 15 would harm California’s solar industry.
Wells Amendment: This amendment would allow the presence or
production of oil or gas to be taken into account when assessing the
fair market value of an oil or gas well for ad valorem property tax
purposes. It is supported by Louisiana’s oil and gas industry.
Louisiana Amendment 5, the Payments in Lieu of Property Taxes Option
Amendment: amends the state constitution to authorize local
governments to enter into a cooperative endeavor agreement with new or
expanding manufacturing establishments – such as the oil and gas
facilities – and allowing the manufacturing establishments to make
payments to the taxing authority of whatever amount instead of paying
property taxes.
“The main lobbying force behind this measure is Cameron, a liquified
natural gas firm,” writes Noor. “Last year, based on a payment in lieu
of taxes agreement, the company paid just $38,000 in taxes. But if it
had to pay their full taxes, it would have paid $220 million. The
company’s agreement is now expiring, so it’s fighting to make it—and
other agreements like it—last forever.”
These kinds of industry tax breaks are why Louisiana stays poor forever,
explains Together Louisiana:
Michigan Proposal 1, the Use of State and Local Park Funds
Amendment: makes changes to how revenue in the state’s park-related
funds can be spent, including (a) making projects to renovate
recreational facilities eligible for grants and (b) requiring that at
least 20% of the parks endowment fund spending be spent on park capital
improvements, and (c) removing the cap on the size of the natural
resources trust fund. The initiative has split the climate movement in
the state, as the measure “would allow Michigan’s Parks Endowment Fund
to sell off oil and gas leases on public lands,” Noor writes. “After
that fund is full, any additional oil and gas money would go into a
Natural Resources Trust Fund, which is also used for natural resources
protection and recreation.”
The Michigan Democratic Party, conservation organizations, and the
Michigan Oil and Gas Association support the measure, but the Michigan
Sierra Club and the Environmental Caucus of the Michigan Democratic
Party stands in opposition.
Renewable Energy Standards Initiative Question 6 (2020) is the
required second vote on the initiative, passed in 2018, to add language
to the Nevada Constitution requiring the state’s Renewable Portfolio
Standard to increase to 50 percent by 2030. In 2018, this ballot
initiative was approved as Question 6, and therefore needs to be
approved again in 2020 to amend the Nevada Constitution. On April 22,
2019, Gov. Steve Sisolak (D) signed Senate Bill 358 (SB 358), which was
designed to require the same RPS percentage by 2030 as the amendment on
the ballot.
New Mexico Constitutional Amendment 1, the Public Regulation
Commission Amendment: changes the utility-oversight Public Regulation
Commission (PRC) from an elected five-member commission to an appointed
three-member commission. New Mexico’s PRC is currently dominated by
fossil-fuel supporters. Climate organizations overwhelmingly support the
amendment.
“Supporters of the measure say that New Mexico is unlikely to meet its
100% clean energy target under its current system because the
commissioners’ elections are so often riddled with corporate money,”
Noor writes. “Under the new system, a bipartisan nominating committee,
which would include at least one representative from a local Indigenous
group, would come up with a list of environmental experts from the
state, and the governor could choose which ones to appoint.”
Local
Albany, A “yes” vote supports authorizing an increase to the utility
users tax from 7% to 9.5% and application of a 7.5% tax on water
service, generating an estimated $675,000 per year for general services
including disaster preparedness, reduction of greenhouse gas emissions,
emergency response and environmental services.
Berkeley, A “yes” vote supports authorizing an increase to the
utility users tax from 7.5% to 10% on electricity and gas and a 2.5%
increase to the gas users tax, generating an estimated $2.4 million per
year for municipal services including reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
Denver, A “yes” vote supports authorizing the city and county of
Denver to levy an additional 0.25% sales tax generating an estimated $40
million per year to fund climate-related programs and programs designed
to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution, thereby increasing
the total sales tax rate in Denver from 8.31% to 8.56%.
Columbus, A “yes” vote supports
authorizing the city to establish an Electric Aggregation Program, which
would allow the city to aggregate the retail electrical load of
customers within the city’s boundaries, and allowing customers to
opt-out of the program. If passed, the City of Columbus will develop a
detailed plan for operation and management of aggregation; include in
the plan a commitment to 100 percent renewable energy; and commit to
encourage development of renewable-energy facilities in Central Ohio.
AEP is financing the
campaign
in support of the initiative. If voters approve the aggregation program,
AEP Energy would lock in most of Ohio’s largest city as its power
customer for up to 15 years; the program would be the largest outside
California, the company says. The initiative is also strongly backed by
local and national environmental organizations and trade
unions.
The Ohio Coal Association stands against the proposal.
Portland, A “yes” vote supports amending the city’s charter to
authorize the city council to spend monies from the Water Fund and
increase rates to cover expenses for general public uses, such as
neighborhood green areas and community gardens.
The various other tax, policing, infrastructure, and campaign finance
initiatives on the ballot have climate justice implications, as do, of
course, the candidate elections.