Boxer Threatens EPA Subpoena; State Previews Legal Arguments 1

Posted by Warming Law Fri, 11 Jan 2008 22:22:00 GMT

(Cross-posted from Warming Law)

Anticipation has been high that Senator Barbara Boxer (D-CA) would use her platform running the Senate Environment and Public Works Commitee to pressure the EPA regarding its denial of California’s waiver application, and a committee field hearing yesterday did not disappoint. Responding to Administrator Stephen Johnson’s no-show and failure to provide documentation of how he reached his decision, Boxer threatened to use the committee’s subpoena power and generally pledged to step up congressional pressure:
“This outrageous decision . . . is completely contrary to the law and science,” Boxer said in a briefing with state officials at Los Angeles City Hall. She held up an empty cardboard box as a symbol of the Environmental Protection Agency’s refusal so far to provide the hefty technical and legal backup that normally accompanies air pollution waiver decisions and are usually published in the Federal Register.

[...]

Johnson is scheduled to testify before the Senate committee in Washington on Jan. 24. An EPA spokesman said, “The official decision documents are being prepared, and they will be released soon.”

California Attorney General Jerry Brown praised Boxer’s subpoena threat, at one point calling Johnson a “stooge in a really pathetic drama that hopefully will not play out much longer.” Brown used his written testimony to document the state’s legal case against the waiver decision, and specifically honed in on EPA’s central assertion that the waiver request did not meet “compelling and extraordinary” conditions due to global warming’s wide-ranging impact.

In addition to reiterating this logic’s departure from the text of the law and the Supreme Court’s rejection of a similar argument in Mass. v. EPA, various testimony directly cited the way in which past waiver decisions have interpreted the law. Former Assembleywoman Fran Pavley—who authored the clean cars law—pointed to a 1984 waiver determination by then-EPA-Administrator William Ruckelshaus deeming that California’s plight need not be “unique” in order to be "compelling and extraordinary." Brown, meanwhile, cited a 1975 waiver determination’s assessment of the Clean Air Act, which noted that:
[I]n the light of their unusually detailed and explicit legislative history. . .Congress meant to ensure by the language it adopted that the Federal government would not second-guess the wisdom of state policy here. . . . Sponsors of the language eventually adopted referred repeatedly to their intent to make sure that no “Federal bureaucrat” would be able to tell the people of California what auto emission standards were good for them, as long as they were stricter than Federal standards.
California Air Resources Board Chairwoman Mary Nichols used her testimony to further undermine EPA’s argument, noting a just-released Stanford study showing that global warming seems to worsen the same localized air-pollution problems in California that everyone agrees spurred Congress to enact the waiver process. David Roberts summarized that study’s impact thusly:
Forthcoming in Geophysical Research Letters, research by engineering professor Mark Jakobson finds a direct causal link between increased CO2 in the atmosphere and increased morbidity from air pollution.

In other words: CO2 makes traditional air pollution – ozone, particulates, carcinogens – more deadly. It follows that states with the worst air pollution have more to fear from climate change.

Trackbacks

This article's trackback address

Comments

Leave a response

  1. dongdong8 Sat, 30 Jun 2018 03:24:51 GMT
    ralph lauren michael kors outlet online fitflop true religion pandora charms air max 90 tory burch uk tory burch bags michael kors canada birkenstock outlet ray ban sunglasses coach factory online marc jacobs stussy hoodie polo ralph lauren ralph lauren polo shirts under armour outlet bvlgari rings ferragamo outlet adidas wings kate spade ralph lauren uk vendita maglie calcio nike blazer y3 shoes coach outlet online adidas ultra boost air jordan polo ralph lauren oakley sunglasses wholesale manchester united jersey off-white shoes wedding shoes nike outlet store belstaff jackets longchamp handbags air max adidas yeezy 350 michael kors ralph lauren christian louboutin swarovski ray ban cheap mlb jerseys pandora jewelry canada supreme uk soccer jerseys pandora jewelry air max 270 michael kors outlet clearance cheap nfl jerseys michael kors taschen fußballtrikots ermäßigung coach outlet mk purse new balance ray ban outlet nike shoes for men tory burch adidas slides adidas football boots ray ban nike lunarglide montblanc cartier jewelry air max plus nike shoes michael kors handbags coach outlet baseball jersey hermes belt giuseppe zanotti shoes hermes bags coach outlet store nike presto kobe 11 polo outlet nike uk michael kors handbags christian louboutin michael kors outlet pandora jewelry longchamp outlet bcbg michael kors uk burberry outlet flip flops adidas yeezy beats headphones jordan 4 louboutin air jordan coach handbags hollister outlet valentino shoes fitflops sale clearance michael kors outlet online kate spade oakley sunglasses cheap tory burch outlet nike tn ralph lauren links of london pandora charms audemars piguet ralph lauren canada goose coach handbags nfl jerseys air jordan shoes oakley vault prada handbags adidas originals carnival shoes nike epic react flyknit michael kors outlet clearance nike outlet online nike free burberry handbags christian louboutin ferragamo supreme michael kors handbags nhl jerseys lebron 15 camisetas de futbol replicas ray ban sunglasses nike free nike dunks nike air huarache cheap oakley sunglasses jordan shoes michael kors handbags hermes soccer shirts adidas outlet air jordan true religion jeans cheap nhl jerseys christian louboutin coach outlet coach outlet online jordans air max 97 louboutin shoes herve leger dresses mont blanc pens michael kors manolo blahnik timberland boots asics oakley sunglasses ralph lauren converse supra shoes air max puma slides air max 95 nike mercurial superfly nfl jerseys nike outlet cheap replica watches roshe run cheap jordan shoes nike outlet prada nike tennis miu miu shoes supreme paris coach outlet nike free run curry shoes adidas uk timberland boots coach outlet online nike shoes asics running shoes nfl jerseys adidas jeremy scott wholesale hats oakley sunglasses louboutin outlet jordan mbt shoes coach outlet online barcelona jersey adidas flip flops air force 1 puma fenty adidas nmd jordans true religion jeans nfl jerseys true religion jeans jordan 8 true religion jeans tory burch balenciaga shoes celine outlet rayban air jordan jordan 6 ray ban birkenstock sandals mulberry coach outlet store online hermes bags baseball bats nike uk michael kors outlet longchamp red bottoms balance shoes undefeated shoes superdry ray bans oakley sunglasses harden vol 2 montblanc pen nike outlet store nike roshe coach factory outlet scarpe mbt nike revolution gucci slides off-white timberland outlet rolex watches adidas outlet coach outlet cheap michael kors bags ralph lauren cheap nfl jerseys jordan 3 kate spade handbags coach adidas superstar swarovski jewelry kevin durant shoes givenchy handbags fingerlings monkey ray ban outlet coach pandora jewelry balenciaga triple s nike outlet store online nike factory new balance sandals oakley sunglasses adidas nmd columbia sportswear ralph lauren timberland camisetas de futbol baratas maglie calcio ferragamo shoes kate spade handbags van cleef & arpels jewelry nike cortez dolce & gabbana yeezy shoes coach factory outlet jordan retro prada outlet online hermes birkin bag basketball shoes kate spade outlet air max michael kors outlet online bottega veneta nike sb coach handbags polo outlet air jordan Fußballtrikots günstig converse shoes wholesale nfl jerseys cheap soccer jerseys longchamp handbags cheap jerseys mishka clothing soccer jersey fitflop cheap nba jerseys dior handbags flip-flops air max 2017 kobe 12 balenciaga sandals vans shoes adidas outlet vibram fivefingers supreme outlet longchamp outlet birkenstock sandals tag heuer watches breitling watches nike shox yeezy 500 coach outlet harden vol 1 air jordan 11 ray ban sunglasses coach outlet online pandora charms jordan xx9 christian louboutin outlet nike air force burberry canada coach outlet air max nike blazer ralph lauren air max 2018 mcm bag pandora jewelry ralph lauren air jordan 14 breguet watches polo ralph nfl jerseys beats by dre jordan 5 suicoke michael kors handbags kate spade purse longchamp vans shoes louboutin prada handbags true religion jeans malone souliers shoes coach outlet online cheap mlb jerseys cheap nfl jerseys jordans timberland boots birkenstock sandals coach outlet online fila shoes nike kyrie 3 mac cosmetics nike air max christian louboutin michael kors outlet nike flip-flops michael kors handbags stuart weitzman shoes running shoes cheap ray bans jordan 12 hermes outlet nike free nike huarache kate spade adidas stan smith dansko shoes michael kors handbags polo ralph lauren prada bags adidas shoes light up shoes flops juicy couture jordan shoes flipflops jordan pas cher oakley canada cheap mlb jerseys air jordan air max 1 maillot de foot longchamp maillot de foot jimmy choo coach outlet burberry alexander mcqueen shoes jordan 1 christian louboutin outlet converse shoes mizuno running shoes tod shoes polo outlet fitflops 20186.30wengdongdong
Comments