UCS at Chamber of Commerce Presentation Against Climate Legislation in New Hampshire 2

Posted by Brad Johnson Sat, 15 Mar 2008 17:17:00 GMT

The Alliance for Energy and Economic Growth (AEEG) (an industry coalition organized in 2001 to support the administration’s Energy Task Force efforts), the National Association of Manufacturers, and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce are hosting a series of state climate change dialogues in 2008 in Ohio, New Hampshire, Montana, and North Dakota, with Margo Thorning of the American Council for Capital Formation, a conservative corporate think tank. The first such forum was held in Manchester, NH on Wednesday, March 12.

Jim Rubens, of the Union of Concerned Scientists attended the event. Below is his story of what transpired, a Hill Heat exclusive.
The American Council for Capital Formation and the U.S. Chamber of Commerce – fronting for coal, oil and the fossil-heavy utilities – last Wednesday road tested their forum on what they claim are the dire economic consequences of the Lieberman-Warner climate bill. It was train wreck I am certain they will not want repeated.

First, in response to a letter from 8 utility CEOs asking that exaggerations be removed from the Charles River Associates analysis forming the basis for the phony projections, lead ExxonMobil-funded economist Dr Margo Thorning announced that no specific impact numbers would be provided. We’d need to wait to see the new, even more slanted ACCF-sponsored study due to be released the next day.

Next, a couple of global warming denialists in the audience asked the Chamber rep why the nation’s business lobby was buying into the need for anything at all to be done, given that glaciers are growing worldwide, Mars is getting colder, etc. The response: the IPCC report is in, and attacking the science is no longer politically tenable. Subtext read in the facial expressions from the dais: we’d love to, but we’re stuck now fear mongering the economics of an American energy future of stable prices, domestic job growth, and intact Florida coastlines.

Next, Tufts economist Dr Julie Nelson asked Dr. Thorning whether the new ACCF-sponsored analysis would be any better than the CRA version, allowing peer review, disclosing assumptions, etc, like all the competing 25 climate-economy models which project only very modest impacts. Answer: an embarrassed no.

Next, yours truly asked Dr. Thorning whether the ACCF analysis – to correct the CRA’s failings – would model the costs of projected warming under the business as usual or baseline scenario at greater than zero, given that New Hampshire’s $650 million ski industry will be wiped out by 2100, or would assign a return greater than zero to stepped-up efficiency and conservation investments, or a value greater than zero for future energy technology innovation. Answer: another hang-dog faced no. Given the lack of data, there is no way to assign any number, she said.

I then asked Dr. Thorning whether it would therefore be fair to footnote the baseline scenario GDP and energy cost numbers, with a statement to the effect that the predicted cost of L-W is high because the baseline number is likely to be low, in that the cost of global warming under business as usual is greater than zero. She acknowledged some merit to that before quickly retreating from the room to work her cell phone.

Recommendations for the three future ACCF fora: be sure to have credible economists and clean energy and efficiency experts and developers in the room. Call them on every false, exaggerated and unsupported statement. Talk about what American entrepreneurs are doing right now in the states where the fora are held to make the American economy stronger while reducing the risks of future climate change. Make sure the media is present to witness it.


This article's trackback address


Leave a response

  1. wwwe Fri, 07 Dec 2018 02:37:18 GMT
    nike air max shoes michael kors outlet jordan 6 birkin bag yeezy adidas nmd r1 air max coach outlet store michael kors outlet handbags adidas stan smith uk kyrie irving shoes adidas gazelle coach factory outlet michael kors outlet online cheap nfl jerseys china off white jordan 1 air max 2017 jordan retro moncler michael kors handbags golden goose slide yeezy fila shoes michael kors outlet supreme clothing kate spade outlet michael kors factory outlet ultra boost 3.0 replica rolex mbt shoes sale adidas yeezy kyrie 4 goyard bag sale jordan shoes air max 2018 adidas stan smith women ferragamo belt nike react flyknit lacoste polo shirts air jordan 11 mbt shoes online nike roshe air jordan shoes nike epic react flyknit kobe 9 curry 5 yeezy boost 350 v2 yeezy boost 350 red bottom shoes harden shoes balenciaga speed off white ultra boost longchamp handbags hermes belt custom baseball jerseys zx flux longchamp hyperdunks converse shoes nike cortez women jordan retro adidas tubular adidas shoes for women russell westbrook shoes adidas yeezy boost adidas ultra boost adidas tubular x nike air force fenty puma golden goose louboutin shoes michael kors factory outlet pure boost adidas yeezy yeezy 700 nike shox pg 1 links of london sale adidas outlet nike react irving shoes hermes belt chrome hearts online fitflops sale goyard handbags balenciaga sneakers off white jordan 1 adidas eqt yeezy boost 350 curry shoes pandora charms kevin durant shoes kobe basketball shoes hermes handbags hermes handbags tote bag yeezy boost chrome hearts outlet adidas ultra boost 3.0 jordan shoes nike flyknit off white clothing yeezy boost 350 nike air max lebron james shoes nike roshe one converse outlet nike huarache nike air max 2019 michael kors outlet online michael kors fila shoes nike air max louboutin shoes salvatore ferragamo belt golden goose sale kd 10 hermes birkin bag lacoste polo shirts lacoste polo yeezy shoes puma fenty off white shoes air jordan 6 chrome hearts outlet air max 2019 calvin klein underwear nike lebron 16 nike air max 2018 air max michael kors outlet nike flyknit trainer goyard tote vapormax air jordan 12 links of london nike air force 1 low kobe shoes cheap jordans kd 11 golden goose francy asics shoes air jordan lebron 13 iniki caterpillar boots yeezy shoes hermes belts golden goose mid star longchamp bape hoodie hermes bag hermes belts nike air max 2017 adidas ultra boost nike air force 1 high nike react moncler vans shoes jordan 11 adidas shoes online coach outlet stores golden goose yeezy shoes yeezy nike basketball shoes yeezy shoes yeezy 500 blush michael kors outlet yeezy shoes off white nike hermes birkin bape hoodie adidas pure boost off-white lebron 16 moncler jackets adidas stan smith cheap nfl jerseys tory burch handbags adidas gazelle sale red bottom shoes for women yeezy boost birkin bag michael kors outlet online adidas superstar coach outlet store moncler outlet hermes michael kors outlet store cheap jordan shoes michael kors outlet nike air vapormax goyard handbags golden goose starter michael kors outlet lebron 15 kyrie 3 nike shoes tory burch outlet adidas yeezy jordan 1 off white michael kors handbags yeezy boost longchamp bags calvin klein outlet jordans yeezy boost 350 v2 longchamp handbags nmd r1 reebok outlet hermes birkin yeezys goyard nike sneakers lebron 14 air max 270 yeezy boost 350 longchamps goyard wallet coach outlet golden goose sneakers fake rolex coach outlet online nike outlet lebron shoes jordan 4 tory burch chrome hearts nike lebron 15 james harden shoes kobe sneakers huaraches nike shox outlet balenciaga polo ralph lauren canada goose nba jerseys valentino golden goose sneakers goyard handbags adidas store lebron shoes lebron 16 shoes kobe 11 adidas iniki runner air jordans longchamp fila outlet kd shoes golden goose outlet balenciaga triple s kobe byrant shoes fila disruptor coach factory outlet michael kors purses yeezy boost 350 v2 balenciaga shoes nike air max chrome hearts moncler hogan outlet hermes birkin supreme clothing rolex replica adidas shoes for men bape clothing lebron 16 moncler jackets golden goose canada goose jacket cheap mlb jerseys off white hoodie nmd jordan shoes adidas tubular adidas yeezy golden goose superstar adidas yeezy outlet golden goose mlb jerseys jordan retro kobe shoes fila shoes michael kors outlet online adidas yeezy boost lacoste online shop crazy explosive paul george shoes adidas shoes valentino shoes stephen curry shoes balenciaga shoes lebron james shoes lacoste outlet yeezy shoes kd 11 lacoste polo longchamp handbags yeezy 500 yeezy 500 hermes handbags hogan outlet online yeezy boost 350 v2 ysl handbags yeezy boost 350 hermes handbags off-white adidas nmd adidas stan smith men gucci belt goyard outlet fila fila disruptor 2 coach outlet store foamposites adidas superstar shoes mbt shoes golden goose sneakers yeezy jordan 13 goyard bags yeezys off white hoodie yeezy sneakers adidas iniki yeezy boost 350 v2 coach outlet michael kors handbags retro jordans goyard online air max yeezy lacoste polo timberland shoes off white jordan 1 golden goose coach outlet jordans adidas nmd yeezys huarache shoes moncler sale vans outlet chrome hearts store nike cortez gucci belts timberland outlet curry 5 lebron 16 authentic jordans adidas nmd balenciaga sneakers kevin durant shoes michael kors outlet nike shox for women fila supreme hoodie cheap jordans golden goose jimmy choo golden goose sneakers longchamp bags fitflops sale clearance nike epic react flyknit kobe 9 michael kors handbags sale ferragamo belt kobe 11 golden goose shoes curry 4 ralph lauren uk curry 4 adidas stan smith huarache shoes cheap jordans hermes belt coach bags sale pureboost air max 90 michael kors nike polo cheapjordans balenciaga speed kobe byrant shoes nike air max 90 yeezy boost 350 nike huarache jordan shoes asics sneakers yeezy boost golden goose coach outlet handbags hermes outlet online adidas flux christian louboutin shoes adidas yeezy caterpillar shoes nike air force 1 yeezy boost 350 v2 pandora bracelet goyard handbags nike hyperdunk michael kors sale jordan 12 jordan retro 13 nhl jerseys rolex replica kd 11 shoes adidas eqt support adv fila online shop rolex replica watches michael kors cheap nba jerseys nmd jimmy choo shoes nike jordans nfl jerseys ferragamo sale kd shoes cheap basketball shoes jordan shoes goyard yeezy wave runner 700 kate spade handbags
  2. qzyfffff Thu, 17 Jan 2019 06:30:26 GMT
    hermes handbags bag ferragamo belts red bottom heels michael kors adidas gazelle nike flyknit racer air force 1 asics running shoes birkin bag rolex replica michael kors factory outlet nfl store yeezy boost kevin durant shoes ferragamo belt yeezy boost 350 ralph lauren uk jordan 11 retro lebron 16 shoes lebron 15 louboutin shoes golden goose outlet nike flyknit yeezy shoes jimmy choo shoes golden goose yeezy boost 350 michael kors outlet polo ralph lauren cheap jordans yeezy shoes retro jordans nike kd 11 nike air max 90 valentino shoes jordan retro nike shox bape hoodie tory burch fila shoes adidas pure boost yeezys coach outlet sale michael kors handbags michael kors handbags yeezys goyard st louis tot hermes handbags for sale nike max air jordan 13 air max 2018 lacoste online shop kd 10 lebron 10 calvin klein outlet kd 11 air jordan 4 jordan retro 6 adidas zx flux reebok shoes longchamp outlet nike shoes lebron 16 yeezy shoes nmd adidas tubular off white shoes fake rolex goyard bags off white clothing chrome hearts longchamp bags hermes belts for men chrome hearts outlet bape hoodie kyrie irving shoes kd shoes jordans nike roshe michael kors handbags adidas superstars harden shoes basketball shoes adidas outlet adidas eqt coach outlet goyard bag adidas yeezy goyard handbags yeezy 700 nike air force 1 balenciaga gucci belt michael jordan shoes golden goose outlet adidas yeezy boost stephen curry 5 kobe shoes lacoste polo adidas nmd michael kors purses goyard jordan sneakers balenciaga triple s adidas iniki birkin bag curry 4 shoes off white adidas tubular adidas ultra mbt shoes online crazy explosive cheap mlb jerseys nike roshe run mbt shoes outlet jordans chrome hearts online fake rolex westbrook shoes vapormax yeezy boost 350 nike air max adidas ultra boost uncaged iniki james harden shoes nike epic react adidas crazy explosive nike hyperdunk yeezy boost 350 moncler jackets fitflops sale clearance yeezy boost 350 adidas yeezy cheap jordans adidas ultra boost cheap jordans cheap nba jerseys michael kors outlet hermes handbags jordan 13 balenciaga sneakers michael kors outlet supreme hoodie kobe byrant shoes canada goose jacket hogan outlet online nike sneakers for women golden goose sneakers 100% real jordans for cheap lebron 16 shoes air max 2019 hermes belt longchamp air max 270 fila sneakers air max 90 michael kors handbags off white hoodie curry 4 ferragamo belt lebron james shoes off white shoes nike basketball shoes lacoste polo yeezy boost adidas shoes outlet yeezy boost lacoste polo nike air max 2018 nike air max 270 cheap nfl jerseys michael kors outlet balenciaga gucci belts coach outlet online coach factory outlet longchamp handbags air jordans lacoste outlet jordan 4 michael kors outlet chrome hearts coach handbags birkin bag balenciaga tory burch sandals moncler jacket jordan shoes golden goose nike vapormax retro jordans zx flux lacoste polo shirts nike epic react kd shoes off white clothing yeezy boost 350 v2 nmd replica rolex reebok outlet pandora jewelry baseball jerseys ysl handbags ysl kobe 9 nike air huarache michael kors outlet online kobe sneakers ralph lauren uk chrome hearts online air max balenciaga shoes lebron 16 adidas stan smith nike polo shirts nike shox for men calvin klein outlet online yeezy boost adidas nmd adidas stan smith sneakers coach outlet nike sneakers for men off white nike cortez ultra boost adidas nmd r1 yeezy golden goose outlet yeezy shoes nike foamposite hermes belt yeezy boost 500 offwhite fila balenciaga shoes yeezy 500 nike cortez men chrome hearts adidas shoes off white lebron 16 yeezy boost 350 v2 ferragamo belts nike sneakers hermes handbags valentino supreme hoodie goyard paul george shoes birkin bag yeezy boost fila adidas yeezy yeezy boost coach outlet online cheap jordans golden goose curry 5 nfl jerseys nike huarache golden goose outlet yeezy boost 350 fila disruptor air jordan jordan shoes goyard handbags nike polo tory burch outlet yeezy shoes lacoste outlet air jordan golden goose nike air max 2019 hermes outlet online hermes birkin adidas superstar yeezy boost 350 yeezy boost 700 hermes online shop red bottoms fila michael kors handbags outlet nike react nike jordans coach outlet kobe 11 hermes belt off white clothing hogan outlet nike air max adidas outlet online jordan 6 jordan shoes Kanye West shoes kobe shoes canada goose yeezy boost 350 goyard handbags golden goose sneakers supreme clothing yeezy boost 350 v2 kyrie 4 shoes jordan retro 12 michael kors handbags hermes bags golden goose sneakers adidas nmd nike air force adidas yeezy jordan shoes jordan 11 yeezy 500 adidas stan smith michael kors uk pandora bracelet kobe 9 yeezy boost 350 kate spade handbags louboutin shoes uk vans outlet vans shoes michael kors outlet online golden goose sneakers off white nike nba jerseys adidas ultra boost mlb jerseys fila shoes yeezy boost 350 v2 timberland boots goyard bag adidas shoes online nike react russell westbrook shoes kyrie 3 golden goose fila kd 11 shoes yeezy shoes adidas tubular shadow kyrie shoes golden goose outlet balenciaga shoes nike lebron 16 pure boost yeezy boost adidas tubular curry 4 golden goose michael kors outlet kd shoes lebron 11 longchamp bags caterpillar boots jordan shoes michael kors handbags coach outlet nhl jerseys kobe 11 converse outlet store kobe basketball shoes jordan 12 adidas nmd runner michael kors fila shoes moncler jackets coach outlet sale lebron 15 shoes red bottom shoes yeezy goyard wallet fake rolex watches yeezy boost 350 v2 jordans lebron shoes nike air max 2017 cat boots off white hoodie adidas stan smith shoes off white x jordan 1 timberland outlet converse outlet longchamp handbags nike air max yeezy boost 350 v2 nike air max coach factory outlet lebron shoes off white jordan 1 christian louboutin tory burch shoes goyard bags asics shoes fila shoes moncler outlet air yeezy cheap nba jerseys fitflops kd 11 adidas eqt support kyrie 4 mbt shoes lacoste nike huarache michael kors outlet online