Pelosi Allies Release Climate Legislation Principles 1

Posted by Brad Johnson Thu, 24 Apr 2008 01:44:00 GMT

Yesterday, Rep. Henry A. Waxman (D-CA), Rep. Ed Markey (D-MA) and Rep. Jay Inslee (D-WA) released a document entitled “Principles for Global Warming Legislation,” saying they “are designed to provide a framework for Congress as it produces legislation to establish an economy-wide mandatory program to cut global warming emissions” and that they “will meet the United States’ obligations to curb greenhouse gas emissions and also will provide a pathway to the international cooperation that is necessary to solve the global warming problem.”

The principles are summarized:

The principles include the following elements: strong science-based targets for near-term and long-term emissions reductions; auctioning emissions allowances rather than giving them to polluting industries; investing auction revenues in clean energy technologies; returning auction proceeds to consumers, workers, and communities to offset any economic impacts; and dedicating a portion of auction proceeds to help states, communities, vulnerable developing countries, and ecosystems address harm from the degree of global warming that is now unavoidable.

The specific 14-point elements provide specific language that is more complicated than the above summary. For example:

  • The document recognizes that an increase in global temperatures greater than 2°C above pre-industrial levels will bring about “dangerous and irreversible changes to the Earth’s climate” and that the IPCC calls for an industrialized-nation minimum target of 25% below 1990 levels by 2020, but calls for a U.S. target of 100% of 1990 levels.
  • The language for scientific lookback provisions would be technically satisfied by Lieberman-Warner’s current provisions (Sec. 7001-7004), which only mandate action by 2020.
  • The document does not actually call for full auction of allowances, saying: “If any allocations are given to polluters, they must be provided only to existing facilities for a brief transition period and the quantity must be limited to avoid windfall profits”; no definition of “brief” or “windfall profits” is given
  • “Significant” auction revenue should be dedicated to “clean energy and efficiency measures” – “clean energy” is defined as “technologies and practices that are cleaner, cheaper, safer, and faster than conventional technologies.” The document does not distinguish between renewable and non-renewable technologies
  • Only clean technology, a priority of Rep. Inslee, is recommended to receive a “significant” portion of auction revenues; however, the document says that auction revenues “sufficient to offset higher energy costs” should go to low- and middle-income households.

The document is written with an eye to the Lieberman-Warner Climate Security Act (S. 2191), the cap-and-trade legislation expected to reach the Senate floor in June. In part, this is because the document is expressly focused on cap-and-trade legislation; questions of broader policy (agriculture, transportation, architecture, urban planning, health) are only touched on. Many of the provisions are written in such a way that the language in Lieberman-Warner satisfies them (such as the 2020 target, lookback provisions, call for complementary policies, and most of the auction proceeds language).

Points of difference include the document’s call for 80% reductions from current levels by 2050 (Lieberman-Warner’s 2050 target is estimated to achieve a 62-66% reduction from current levels) and the emphasis on auction rather than allowance giveaways. Lieberman-Warner allocates a significant percentage of allowances for public purposes, giving them to states, tribal governments, federal agencies, and load-serving entities who would then sell the allowances to emitters to use their value; this document emphasizes instead using auction revenues.

In general, the House document is in line with the Sanders-Lautenberg principles, though Sanders-Lautenberg is stronger on the scientific language. However, it is considerably less aggressive than the progressive 1Sky principles. For example, there is no language even hinting at a coal plant moratorium, which has been called for by Reps. Waxman and Markey (H.R. 5575).

The full document of principles is after the jump.

LETTER on PRINCIPLES for CLIMATE LEGISLATION

The Honorable Nancy Pelosi
Speaker
U.S. House of Representatives
Washington, DC 20515

Dear Madam Speaker,

We salute your leadership on one of the critical issues of our time: the effort to save the planet from calamitous global warming. You have listened to the scientists and recognized the scope and severity of the threat that global warming poses to our nation’s security, economy, public health, and ecosystems. You have made enacting legislation to address global warming a top priority for Congress for the first time in our history. We stand ready to help develop this legislation and enact it into law.

As part of this effort, we have developed a set of principles to guide Congress as it produces legislation to establish an economy-wide mandatory program to address the threat of global warming. Acting in accordance with these principles is critical to achieving a fair and effective bill that will avoid the most dangerous global warming and assist those harmed by the warming that is unavoidable, while strengthening our economy.

The following are the principles we have developed to guide the creation of comprehensive global warming legislation.

Comprehensive legislation to address global warming must achieve four key goals:

  1. Reduce emissions to avoid dangerous global warming;
  2. Transition America to a clean energy economy;
  3. Recognize and minimize any economic impacts from global warming legislation; and
  4. Aid communities and ecosystems vulnerable to harm from global warming.
To meet each of these goals, climate change legislation must include the following key elements.

Reduce Emissions to Avoid Dangerous Global Warming

The United States must do its part to keep global temperatures from rising more than 3.6 degrees Fahrenheit (2 degrees Celsius) above pre-industrial levels. The scientific community warns that above this level, dangerous and irreversible changes to the Earth’s climate are predicted to occur. To meet this goal, the legislation must:
  • Cap and cut global warming emissions to science-based levels with short and long-term targets. Total U.S. emissions must be capped by a date certain, decline every year, be reduced to 15% to 20% below current levels in 2020, and fall to 80% below 1990 levels by 2050.
  • Review and respond to advancing climate science. The effects of global warming are happening much faster than scientists predicted several years ago, and there may be tipping points at which irreversible effects occur at lower levels of greenhouse gas concentrations than previously predicted. A mechanism for periodic scientific review is necessary, and EPA, and other agencies as appropriate, must adjust the regulatory response if the latest science indicates that more reductions are needed.
  • Make emissions targets certain and enforceable. Our strong existing environmental laws depend on enforceable requirements, rigorous monitoring and reporting of emissions, public input and transparent implementation, and government and citizen enforcement. All of these elements must be included in comprehensive global warming legislation. Cost-containment measures must not break the cap on global warming pollution. Any offsets must be real, additional, verifiable, permanent, and enforceable. The percentage of required emissions reductions that may be met with offsets should be strictly limited, and should be increased only to the extent that there is greater certainty that the offsets will not compromise the program’s environmental integrity.
  • Require the United States to engage with other nations to reduce emissions through commitments and incentives. The United States must reengage in the international negotiations to establish binding emissions reductions goals under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. The legislation must encourage developing countries to reduce emissions by assisting such countries to avoid deforestation and to adopt clean energy technologies. This is a cost-effective way for the United States and other developed nations to achieve combined emissions reductions of at least 25% below 1990 levels by 2020, as called for by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.

Transition America to a Clean Energy Economy

Global warming legislation provides an opportunity to create new jobs, while transforming the way we live and work through renewable energy, green buildings, clean vehicles, and advanced technologies. To realize this opportunity, the legislation must:

  • Invest in the best clean energy and efficiency technologies. A significant portion of revenues from auctioning emissions allowances should be invested in clean energy and efficiency measures, targeted to technologies and practices that are cleaner, cheaper, safer, and faster than conventional technologies, as determined through the application of clear standards set by Congress.
  • Include and encourage complementary policies. Complementary policies can lower program costs by producing lower-cost emissions reductions from economic sectors and activities that are less sensitive to a price signal. Smart growth measures, green building policies, and electricity sector efficiency policies are important types of complementary policies. The legislation should include federal complementary policies and encourage state and local complementary policies in areas better addressed by states and localities.
  • Preserve states’ authorities to protect their citizens. Federal global warming requirements must be a floor, not a ceiling, on states’ ability to protect their citizens’ health and state resources. Throughout our history, states have pioneered policies that the nation has subsequently adopted. Addressing global warming requires state and local efforts, as well as national ones.

Recognize and Minimize Any Economic Impacts from Global Warming Legislation

Reducing global warming pollution will likely have some manageable costs, which would be far lower than the costs of inaction. To minimize any economic impacts, the legislation must:
  • Use public assets for public benefit in a fair and transparent way. Emissions allowances should be auctioned with the revenues going to benefit the public, and any free allocations should produce public benefits. If any allocations are given to polluters, they must be provided only to existing facilities for a brief transition period and the quantity must be limited to avoid windfall profits.
  • Return revenues to consumers. Revenues from auctioned allowances should be returned to low- and moderate-income households at a level sufficient to offset higher energy costs.
  • Return revenues to workers and communities. Workers and communities most affected by the transition to a clean energy economy should receive a portion of the revenues to ease the transition and build a trained workforce so that all can participate in the new energy economy.
  • Protect against global trade disadvantages to U.S. industry. In addition to providing incentives for developing countries to reduce emissions, the legislation should provide for an effective response to any countries that refuse to contribute their fair share to the international effort. These elements will protect energy-intensive U.S. enterprises against competitive disadvantage.

Aid Communities and Ecosystems Vulnerable to Harm from Global Warming

Global warming is already harming communities and ecosystems throughout the world, and even with immediate action to reduce emissions and avoid dangerous effects, these impacts will worsen over the coming decades. To ameliorate these harms, the legislation must:
  • Assist states, localities and tribes to respond and adapt to the effects of global warming. A portion of auction revenues should be provided to states, localities, and tribes to respond to harm from global warming and adapt their infrastructure to its effects, such as more severe wildfires, intensified droughts, increased water scarcity, sea level rise, floods, hurricanes, melting permafrost, and agricultural and public health impacts.
  • Assist developing countries to respond and adapt to the effects of global warming. A portion of auction revenues should be provided to help the developing countries most vulnerable to harm from global warming and defuse the threats to national security and global stability posed by conflicts over water and other natural resources, famines, and mass migrations that could be triggered by global warming. Vulnerable countries include least developed countries, where millions of people are already living on the brink, and small island states, which face massive loss of land.
  • Assist wildlife and ecosystems threatened by global warming. A portion of auction revenues should be provided to federal, state, and tribal natural resource protection agencies to manage wildlife and ecosystems to maximize the survival of wildlife populations, imperiled species, and ecosystems, using science-based adaptation strategies.

These principles, if adopted as part of comprehensive climate change legislation, will meet the United States’ obligations to curb greenhouse gas emissions and also will provide a pathway to the international cooperation that is necessary to solve the global warming problem.

Trackbacks

This article's trackback address

Comments

Leave a response

  1. cai123 Wed, 17 Oct 2018 01:10:30 GMT
    cai123 10.17 canada goose outlet store canada goose birkenstock shoes coach outlet store online salvatore ferragamo outlet salomon outlet orioles jerseys canada goose outlet online discount oakley sunglasses tory burch handbags uggs outlet store coach outlet online pandora charms pandora charms sale clearance coach factorty outlet online kate spade outlet online pandora charms outlet ysl handbags nike cortez classic uggs outlet store timberland shoes astros jerseys coach outlet online pandora outlet store red bottom heels michael kors outlet store yeezy boost 350 michael kors canada adidas stan smith uggs outlet coach outlet online michael kors outlet canada michael kors outlet online timberland shoes jimmy choo shoes true religion jeans coach factory outlet ronaldo jerseys ralph lauren uk michael kors outlet clearance coach outlet online canada goose coats ugg boots outlet ysl outlet oakley sunglasses outlet supreme shirts adidas superstar shoes moncler outlet reebok outlet adidas originals coach factory outlet online cheap oakley sunglasses coach outlet store online pandora jewelry outlet fake rolex fitflops sale gucci outlet store canada goose coats birkenstock shoes outlet ray bans adidas outlet coach outlet online michael kors outlet online coach outlet online louboutin outlet nike huarache shoes cheap jordans birkenstock outlet store north face outlet store adidas nmd r1 tory burch outlet store pandora charms sale clearance adidas outlet store nike tessen kate spade outlet online coach factorty outlet store coach outlet online nike shoes pandora charms outlet ugg outlet cheap jordan shoes louis vuitton outlet online ugg boots outlet adidas sneakers michael kors toms outlet online uggs outlet coach factory outlet air max yeezy shoes converse outlet ralph lauren sale christian louboutin shoes coach outlet store online coach outlet online pandora jewelry michael kors outlet clearance ugg outlet online coach outlet online ugg boots pandora charms sale coach outlet store online clearance oakley sunglasses wholesale polo ralph lauren outlet online white sox jerseys pandora outlet cheap oakley sunglasses coach factory outlet online birkin handbags pandora jewelry outlet coach outlet canada indians jerseys birkenstock outlet birkenstock outlet store fitflops sale jimmy choo cheap ray ban sunglasses louis vuitton outlet store moncler coats timberland outlet toms shoes nfl jerseys birkenstock sandals nike zoom cheap ray ban sunglasses kate spade bags coach factory outlet online supreme shirts philipp plein ralph lauren outlet online polo ralph lauren pandora jewelry pg 2 shoes coach outlet timberland boots ugg outlet store columbia shoes uggs outlet nike outlet store gucci outlet online cheap jordans for sale louboutin outlet coach factorty outlet store nike shoes outlet tiffany and co jewelry coach outlet online uggs outlet coach outlet online nike outlet store lebron james shoes air max 1 canada goose coach factory outlet online ralph lauren sale coach outlet online hermes bag louboutin shoes air more uptempo longchamp outlet moncler outlet moncler coats fitflop sandals adidas yeezy shoes salvatore ferragamo christian louboutin shoes kate spade purses coach factory outlet online birkenstock sale pandora sale clearance kate spade outlet coach factory outlet online pandora charms sale clearance prada shoes louis vuitton outlet online air max outlet new balance outlet coach factory outlet online nike dunks ugg outlet longchamp uggs outlet kate spade outlet online canada goose christian louboutin shoes kate spade handbags marlins jerseys ugg outlet store canadian goose ray ban glasses kate spade outlet online air max canada goose coach outlet store tory burch outlet online kate spade handbags coach outlet online ugg outlet nike air presto adidas outlet online birkenstock uk nike free 5.0 pandora jewelry reds jerseys kate spade handbag ralph lauren sale clearance uk dr martens boots city royals jerseys ugg boots louis vuitton outlet coach canada kate spade handbags adidas outlet store cheap oakley sunglasses rolex replica watches canada goose timberland boots outlet swarovski crystal adidas nmd runner coach outlet online air max shoes coach outlet store online ugg boots pandora canada canada goose jackets birkenstock outlet nmd adidas columbia outlet coach factory outlet online burberry outlet store mont blanc pens fitflop sandals michael kors swarovski outlet coach outlet online canada goose outlet store uggs on sale moncler outlet store kobe shoes ecco outlet pandora charms outlet kate spade outlet fitflops sale clearance brewers jerseys longchamp outlet rolex replica watches for sale ralph lauren adidas nmd r1 pandora jewelry store coach outlet store online mets jerseys adidas shoes michael kors outlet online mont blanc pen diamondbacks jerseys hermes bags cheap air jordans underarmour outlet polo ralph lauren outlet pandora charms moncler outlet ecco shoes adidas shoes coach outlet pandora jewelry canada goose jackets nike zoom shoes ugg outlet store michael kors handbags polo outlet online louis vuitton factory outlet fred perry polo shirts adidas yeezy boost louis vuitton handbags coach factory outlet pirates jerseys moncler outlet online kate spade handbags ugg boots nike air max 2018 michael kors outlet salvatore ferragamo shoes ugg outlet store cartier watches kyrie 4 asics outlet nike sneakers ralph lauren outlet online adidas superstars canada goose outlet store canada goose parka nike outlet online mariners jerseys jordan shoes nike shoes pandora charms outlet nike outlet store kate spade outlet online cheap jordan shoes michael kors outlet online kate spade outlet online pandora charms sale discount oakley sunglasses vans outlet kate spade outlet online kate spade outlet online nike air max 2018 coach bags coach factory outlet coach factory outlet online lacoste polo shirts coach factory outlet canada goose outlet ralph lauren uk michael kors outlet clearance nike air max 97 canada goose outlet dr martens nike air max 97 michael kors outlet store air max shoes nike sneakers nike free 3.0 ralph lauren uk basketball shoes ugg outlet store canada goose nike react shoes coach factory outlet online hermes outlet ralph lauren angels jerseys ugg outlet online jordan shoes moncler outlet store uggs outlet pandora jewelry red bottom yeezy boost 350 moncler outlet store canada goose jackets new balance outlet store tory burch outlet online ugg outlet red bottoms adidas outlet online rockies jerseys burberry outlet mulberry uk michael kors outlet store retro 11 air max 87 coach outlet canada christian louboutin shoes supra for sale fitflop shoes air max 95 cheap nfl jerseys wholesale canada goose coats pandora charms outlet uggs outlet moncler outlet online birkenstock outlet online ugg boots nike running shoes jordan shoes for sale canada goose outlet store asics outlet store michael kors handbags ecco outlet true religion outlet store supreme uk philipp plein outlet nike cortez classic michael kors canada pandora charms outlet canada goose sale pandora charms polo ralph lauren outlet online polo ralph lauren outlet online ugg outlet nike air max 2019 louis vuitton factory outlet pandora outlet cheap jordans kate spade handbags hermes bags cheap jordan shoes fitflop sandals cheap air max ugg boots outlet nfl jerseys coach factory outlet online michael kors outlet clearance michael kors outlet clearance cheap air jordans jordans adidas nmd r1 polo ralph lauren outlet ugg outlet coach outlet online air max 90 ugg boots louboutin shoes pandora jewelry tiffany and co outlet ugg outlet online coach outlet store online yeezy shoes converse all star fitflops uk fitflop uk cheap jordans cheap ray ban sunglasses nike outlet store online nike shox shoes ugg canada christian louboutin shoes timberland outlet jimmy choo outlet michael kors outlet online ugg outlet oakley sunglasses outlet fred perry outlet canada goose outlet padres jerseys canada goose outlet store vans outlet store yeezy boost 350 prada outlet online cheap oakley sunglasses twins jerseys ralph lauren uk supra for sale michael kors outlet store rangers jersey michael kors outlet valentino outlet michael kors outlet store coach factory outlet uggs outlet ralph lauren outlet online kate spade outlet online michael kors outlet store adidas outlet online canadian goose jacket michael kors bags dodgers jerseys cheap jordan shoes devil rays jerseys mlb jerseys cheap yeezy shoes north face jackets yeezy boost adidas outlet store kate spade handbags canada goose outlet kate spade outlet store pandora charms sale kate spade bags air more money moncler ugg shoes ralph lauren sale clearance uk moncler outlet online coach canada outlet uggs outlet online christian louboutin sale cheap air jordans ugg canada adidas ultra boost skechers outlet pandora rings fendi handbags gucci outlet online coach factorty outlet online coach outlet online kate spade outlet kobe shoes canada goose jacket canada goose outlet cheap nike shoes ugg outlet online coach outlet canada nike huarache shoes rolex replica watches michael kors outlet online louis vuitton outlet athletics jerseys fitflops sale toms outlet store nike outlet nike air max zero ugg outlet online timberland outlet durant shoes air jordan shoes coach factory outlet air jordans canada goose jackets coach outlet canada moncler outlet online ugg boots polo ralph lauren outlet air jordan retro cheap jordan shoes kate spade purses blue jays jerseys ecco outlet dr martens boots timberland shoes converse shoes ralph lauren outlet online christian louboutin sale longchamp outlet online adidas yeezy adidas yeezy boost 350 adidas store supreme clothing coach outlet online mlb jerseys wholesale pandora charms nike outlet coach outlet store braves jerseys adidas campus shoes coach factory outlet online ecco shoes for women mulberry outlet uk nike outlet online moncler coats cheap jordans free shipping nike air max 90 ugg outlet store discount oakley sunglasses moncler jackets coach factory outlet online dansko shoes pandora jewelry outlet tiffany outlet cheap jordan shoes coach factory outlet online cai123 10.17
Comments