Kempthorne: Polar Bear 'Threatened' By Decline of Arctic Sea Ice, But Drilling Can Continue 2

Posted by Wonk Room Thu, 15 May 2008 12:16:00 GMT

Originally posted at the Wonk Room.

After years of delay, Secretary of the Interior Dirk Kempthorne made a landmark decision on whether global warming pollution is regulated by the Endangered Species Act (ESA). Kempthorne ruled that the polar bear should be classified as a “threatened species” due to the decline of polar sea ice, critical to its survival. Kempthorne stated:

They are likely to become endangered in the near future.

The Department of Interior, under Secretary Dirk Kempthorne, fought for several years in the courts since 2005 to avoid making a decision on whether the precipitous decline in Arctic sea ice due to global warming is making the polar bear an endangered species. Fish and Wildlife Service director Dale Hall testified in January that there was no significant scientific uncertainty in the endangerment posed by global warming to polar bears—the only legal justification under the Endangered Species Act for a delay.

Kempthone’s decision to follow the science is in marked contrast to Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Stephen Johnson’s action to override his staff in refusing to regulate tailpipe greenhouse gas emissions.

However, Kempthorne also argued vigorously that his decison does not compel the Bush administration to construct a plan to regulate greenhouse gas emissions, repeating President Bush’s entirely spurious claim that would be a “wholly inappropriate use” of the Endangered Species Act. The Interior news release announces, “Rule will allow continuation of vital energy production in Alaska.” Kempthorne claimed that the Marine Mammal Protection Act (MMPA) is “more stringent” than the ESA, despite the court ruling that compelled him to make today’s ruling stating that “the protections afforded under the ESA far surpass those provided by the MMPA.”

Despite his protestations, Kempthorne’s decision clearly calls into question the legality of the sale of oil and gas drilling rights in polar bear habitat on February 6, while the polar bear decision was being illegally delayed.

Kempthorne complained that the Endangered Species Act is “one of the most inflexible” pieces of legislation because it didn’t allow him to consider economic impacts when protecting species like the polar bear from extinction.

From the Department of Interior press release on the 368-page rule:
To make sure the ESA is not misused to regulate global climate change, Kempthorne promised the following actions:
  • The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is proposing a 4(d) rule that states that if an activity is permissible under the stricter standards of the Marine Mammal Protection Act, it is also permissible under the ESA with respect to the polar bear. This rule, effective immediately, will ensure the protection of the bear while allowing us to continue to develop our natural resources in the arctic region in an environmentally sound way.
  • Director Hall will issue guidance to staff that the best scientific data available today cannot make a causal connection between harm to listed species or their habitats and greenhouse gas emissions from a specific facility, or resource development project or government action.
  • The Department will issue a Solicitor’s Opinion further clarifying these points.
  • The Department will propose common sense modifications to the existing ESA regulatory language to prevent abuse of this listing to erect a back-door climate policy outside our normal system of political accountability.

Andy Revkin at Dot Earth concludes, “So this leaves everything as it was, in a way, with the bears facing a transforming ecosystem and environmentalists successful in their litigation, but not necessarily empowered by the listing.” At Climate Progress Joe Romm calls the decision “bye-polar disorder.”

Sierra Club spokesman Josh Dorner tells the Wonk Room, “This is the regulatory equivalent of a signing statement—only this one gets to be challenged in court.”

Trackbacks

This article's trackback address

Comments

Leave a response

  1. dongdong8 Sat, 30 Jun 2018 03:24:51 GMT
    ralph lauren michael kors outlet online fitflop true religion pandora charms air max 90 tory burch uk tory burch bags michael kors canada birkenstock outlet ray ban sunglasses coach factory online marc jacobs stussy hoodie polo ralph lauren ralph lauren polo shirts under armour outlet bvlgari rings ferragamo outlet adidas wings kate spade ralph lauren uk vendita maglie calcio nike blazer y3 shoes coach outlet online adidas ultra boost air jordan polo ralph lauren oakley sunglasses wholesale manchester united jersey off-white shoes wedding shoes nike outlet store belstaff jackets longchamp handbags air max adidas yeezy 350 michael kors ralph lauren christian louboutin swarovski ray ban cheap mlb jerseys pandora jewelry canada supreme uk soccer jerseys pandora jewelry air max 270 michael kors outlet clearance cheap nfl jerseys michael kors taschen fußballtrikots ermäßigung coach outlet mk purse new balance ray ban outlet nike shoes for men tory burch adidas slides adidas football boots ray ban nike lunarglide montblanc cartier jewelry air max plus nike shoes michael kors handbags coach outlet baseball jersey hermes belt giuseppe zanotti shoes hermes bags coach outlet store nike presto kobe 11 polo outlet nike uk michael kors handbags christian louboutin michael kors outlet pandora jewelry longchamp outlet bcbg michael kors uk burberry outlet flip flops adidas yeezy beats headphones jordan 4 louboutin air jordan coach handbags hollister outlet valentino shoes fitflops sale clearance michael kors outlet online kate spade oakley sunglasses cheap tory burch outlet nike tn ralph lauren links of london pandora charms audemars piguet ralph lauren canada goose coach handbags nfl jerseys air jordan shoes oakley vault prada handbags adidas originals carnival shoes nike epic react flyknit michael kors outlet clearance nike outlet online nike free burberry handbags christian louboutin ferragamo supreme michael kors handbags nhl jerseys lebron 15 camisetas de futbol replicas ray ban sunglasses nike free nike dunks nike air huarache cheap oakley sunglasses jordan shoes michael kors handbags hermes soccer shirts adidas outlet air jordan true religion jeans cheap nhl jerseys christian louboutin coach outlet coach outlet online jordans air max 97 louboutin shoes herve leger dresses mont blanc pens michael kors manolo blahnik timberland boots asics oakley sunglasses ralph lauren converse supra shoes air max puma slides air max 95 nike mercurial superfly nfl jerseys nike outlet cheap replica watches roshe run cheap jordan shoes nike outlet prada nike tennis miu miu shoes supreme paris coach outlet nike free run curry shoes adidas uk timberland boots coach outlet online nike shoes asics running shoes nfl jerseys adidas jeremy scott wholesale hats oakley sunglasses louboutin outlet jordan mbt shoes coach outlet online barcelona jersey adidas flip flops air force 1 puma fenty adidas nmd jordans true religion jeans nfl jerseys true religion jeans jordan 8 true religion jeans tory burch balenciaga shoes celine outlet rayban air jordan jordan 6 ray ban birkenstock sandals mulberry coach outlet store online hermes bags baseball bats nike uk michael kors outlet longchamp red bottoms balance shoes undefeated shoes superdry ray bans oakley sunglasses harden vol 2 montblanc pen nike outlet store nike roshe coach factory outlet scarpe mbt nike revolution gucci slides off-white timberland outlet rolex watches adidas outlet coach outlet cheap michael kors bags ralph lauren cheap nfl jerseys jordan 3 kate spade handbags coach adidas superstar swarovski jewelry kevin durant shoes givenchy handbags fingerlings monkey ray ban outlet coach pandora jewelry balenciaga triple s nike outlet store online nike factory new balance sandals oakley sunglasses adidas nmd columbia sportswear ralph lauren timberland camisetas de futbol baratas maglie calcio ferragamo shoes kate spade handbags van cleef & arpels jewelry nike cortez dolce & gabbana yeezy shoes coach factory outlet jordan retro prada outlet online hermes birkin bag basketball shoes kate spade outlet air max michael kors outlet online bottega veneta nike sb coach handbags polo outlet air jordan Fußballtrikots günstig converse shoes wholesale nfl jerseys cheap soccer jerseys longchamp handbags cheap jerseys mishka clothing soccer jersey fitflop cheap nba jerseys dior handbags flip-flops air max 2017 kobe 12 balenciaga sandals vans shoes adidas outlet vibram fivefingers supreme outlet longchamp outlet birkenstock sandals tag heuer watches breitling watches nike shox yeezy 500 coach outlet harden vol 1 air jordan 11 ray ban sunglasses coach outlet online pandora charms jordan xx9 christian louboutin outlet nike air force burberry canada coach outlet air max nike blazer ralph lauren air max 2018 mcm bag pandora jewelry ralph lauren air jordan 14 breguet watches polo ralph nfl jerseys beats by dre jordan 5 suicoke michael kors handbags kate spade purse longchamp vans shoes louboutin prada handbags true religion jeans malone souliers shoes coach outlet online cheap mlb jerseys cheap nfl jerseys jordans timberland boots birkenstock sandals coach outlet online fila shoes nike kyrie 3 mac cosmetics nike air max christian louboutin michael kors outlet nike flip-flops michael kors handbags stuart weitzman shoes running shoes cheap ray bans jordan 12 hermes outlet nike free nike huarache kate spade adidas stan smith dansko shoes michael kors handbags polo ralph lauren prada bags adidas shoes light up shoes flops juicy couture jordan shoes flipflops jordan pas cher oakley canada cheap mlb jerseys air jordan air max 1 maillot de foot longchamp maillot de foot jimmy choo coach outlet burberry alexander mcqueen shoes jordan 1 christian louboutin outlet converse shoes mizuno running shoes tod shoes polo outlet fitflops 20186.30wengdongdong
  2. xukaimin Wed, 18 Jul 2018 02:19:02 GMT
    adidas superstar adidas outlet mulberry toms outlet jordan 8 mizuno air max 2018 hollister bathing ape clarisonic mia nike air max cheap wedding dresses herve leger dresses guess nike roshe celine handbags chrome hearts jewelry nike air max jordan 14 jordan xx9 prada hogan ray ban pandora charms montre pas cher supra shoes adidas crazy pandora uk true religion ray ban pas cher mac makeup mont blanc pens nike air max asics running shoes argentina world cup jersey omega watches nike air max lacoste shoes hermes birkin harry winston jewelry longchamp outlet dsquared2 jeans burberry outlet jordan clothing nike pas cher vans pas cher asics gel michael kors handbags kd 9 kevin durant shoes cheap oakley sunglasses swarovski crystal jordan 3 soccer jerseys dansko shoes curry 2 christian louboutin pas cher michael jordan ai max mulberry handbags nike store guess handbags air jordan portugal world cup jersey bvlgari sunglasses ferragamo vans outlet valentino nike air max 2017 dior sunglasses burberry sunglasses nike free rolex watches roshe run coach outlet online mont blanc pens furla handbags sac michael kors calvin klein outlet kids jordans kd 10 10 deep clothing salomon shoes belgium world cup jerseys g-star jeans softball bats ed hardy jordan 2 jbl headphones giuseppe zanotti outlet lululemon outlet adidas zx flux lebron 11 kevin durant shoes aaron rodgers jersey cartier sunglasses kevin durant jersey nike roshe michael jordan guess canada golden goose sneakers nike air max dsquared2 outlet michael kors uk basket nike nfl jerseys orologi rolex fendi iphone cases reebok shoes adidas shoes nike roshe tommy hilfiger germany world cup jersey nike free run chanel outlet balmain jeans wedding dress nike store longchamp pas cher jordan pas cher christian louboutin champion clothing jordans lunette oakley thomas sabo uk ai max nike outlet store dolce & gabbana sunglasses bottega veneta sunglasses dyson hair dryer michael kors outlet ferragamo sunglasses coach outlet givenchy handbags lebron shoes nike air force 1 polo ralph lauren michael kors uk carson wentz jersey hermes bags converse adidas running shoes kyrie 4 reebok shoes tommy hilfiger freshjive clothing nike air max cheap jordans dak prescott jersey kobe 10 nike shoes tn pas cher hermes armani handbags nike roshe run nike air max 90 nike air zoom pegasus air max 90 converse uk nike air max jordan shoes christian louboutin spain world cup jersey basketball jersey chanel outlet fendi sunglasses burberry clothing air force one lebron shoes mac cosmetics online air max plus burberry sale nike roshe run air max 90 jordan fitflops ray ban sunglasses jordan mac makeup insanity workout rolex watches jordan 3 pandora jewelry air max 95 burberry stuart weitzman shoes nike air max kates pade outlet online pandora bijoux salvatore ferragamo sac vanessa bruno asics gel adidas slides tory burch lunette ray ban adidas outlet store ralph lauren outlet cheap oakley sunglasses ralph lauren outlet cheap wedding dresses nike kyrie 2 adidas flip-flops christian louboutin supra shoes chi flat iron converse nike outlet nike mercurial nike huarache converse shoes designer sunglasses nike roshe run toms shoes jimmy choo nike air max 95 adidas soccer cleats ralph lauren polo ralph lauren gucci belt armani jeans cheap jerseys hermes jewelry dior bags nike outlet michael kors outlet nike free run links of london uk parajumpers swarovski gioielli guess factory oakley sunglasses ray ban pandora charms air max michael kors mac cosmetics nike uk insanity workout chloe handbags montre homme bcbg dresses keen sandals kyrie irving jersey nike vapor max polo lacoste pas cher bijoux swarovski burberry kobe 11 tiffany jewelry kristaps porzingis jersey antonio brown jersey marc jacobs handbags nike free converse all stars ghd gucci shoes furla handbags jordan 7 ferragamo shoes clarks shoes tory burch outlet dolce & gabbana france world cup jersey jordan prada sunglasses adidas outlet store scarpe hogan reebok outlet bottega veneta replica watches cheap jerseys oakley sunglasses converse outlet store abercrombie and fitch air max 90 cheap jordan shoes nike shoes new balance soldes nfl jerseys nike free new balance femme dolce & gabbana karen millen adidas originals nike air max 90 cartier bracelet jordan 4 beats by dre bcbg max azria polo ralph lauren chaussure nike oakley uk karen millen longchamp outlet huf clothing swarovski jewelry air more uptempo polo ralph lauren armani sunglasses coach factory outlet adidas soccer calvin klein jeans jordan 11 bottega veneta saint laurent handbags michael kors vans outlet michael kors stuart weitzman timberland boots miu miu shoes gentle monster sunglasses giannis antetokounmpo jersey ray ban sunglasses skechers sneakers carrera sunglasses prada handbags isabel marant shoes nike blazer jordan bose headphones nike shoes adidas outlet store converse chuck taylor ferragamo belt nike foamposite hogan shoes jordan 12 yeezy shoes basketball shoes louboutin outlet fossil handbags longchamp mizuno curry 5 true religion jeans beats headphones sac michael kors sac longchamp james harden jersey barbour nike shoes ray ban sunglasses nike mercurial instyler nike mercurial superfly pandora bracciali chloe sunglasses oakley pas cher goyard handbags dansko outlet diesel jeans curry 4 michael kors handbags gucci outlet replica watches air jordan ghd hair straighteners jordan 32 burberry outlet nike canada fendi handbags beats pill new balance shoes ferragamo shoes nike air max 2017 softball bats fitflops longchamp handbags jimmy choo sunglasses lululemon outlet marc jacobs handbags lacoste jeans kenzo clothing flip flops longchamp handbags kobe 12 true religion adidas clothing timberland boots nike free run nike air max 97 arcteryx jackets insanity beats headphones abercrombie babyliss pro nano titanium vans scarpe michael kors canada basket store marc jacobs handbags adidas superstar chopard jewelry puma shoes bally shoes boy london clothing mizuno running shoes asics trainers replica watches nike outlet ghd flat iron bape clothing barbour jackets jordan 1 pandora jewelry kobe 9 elite adidas outlet store nike blazer hollister outlet occhiali oakley red bottom shoes chloe handbags jordan 13 jordan 9 givenchy jewelry oakley vault kate spade nike air max alife clothing prada outlet air max louboutin pas cher kobe bryant shoes timberland pas cher jordan 6 true religion outlet prom dresses ray ban sunglasses ray ban occhiali ralph lauren curry 3 nike clothing burberry handbags gucci outlet jordan 10 oakley sunglasses michael kors outlet hermes bags nike factory tommy hilfiger pas cher tory burch air force 1 ferragamo manolo blahnik shoes polo ralph lauren jordan 6 abercrombie dolce & gabbana brazil world cup jersey oakley glasses jordan 31 oakley sunglasses montres fitflops outlet versace handbags bulgari jewelry new balance trainer true religion jeans abercrombie balenciaga sneakers nike outlet online ray ban sunglasses christian louboutin shoes jimmy choo shoes new balance shoes michael jordan vibram fivefingers chrome hearts jewelry michael kors outlet true religion outlet nike free run adidas trainers uk jordan 4 chanel handbags michael kors outlet online alexander mcqueen handbags new balance coach purse jordan 5 christian louboutin kate spade uk nike blazer tods shoes england world cup jersey iphone x case nike air gucci handbags 2018.7.18xukaimin
Comments