Dingell and Boucher Unveil Draft Climate Legislation 1

Posted by Wonk Room Wed, 08 Oct 2008 21:24:00 GMT

From the Wonk Room.

Dingell, stepping it upAs the 110th Congress comes to a close, two of the legislators in charge of climate legislation in the House of Representatives yesterday released a draft climate plan. Rep. John Dingell (D-MI), the powerful chair of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, and Rep. Rick Boucher (D-VA), chair of the Energy and Air Quality subcommittee, have primary jurisdiction in the House for legislation that puts mandatory limits on carbon emissions. Although such legislation has been a top priority for Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) since she became Speaker of the House in January 2007, Dingell and Boucher declared they would not be rushed, instead working on the 2007 energy bill, holding several hearings and releasing four white papers from October to May of this year. Dingell’s district is in the heart of the U.S. auto industry; Boucher represents Virginia’s coal country. Below is an analysis of some of the key issues raised in their 460-page draft legislation, an ambitious effort by the two congressmen.

EMISSIONS TARGETS. Dingell and Boucher call for emissions reductions of 80 percent from 2005 levels by 2050, in line with the minimum of scientific recommendations, but with reductions of only six percent below 2005 levels by 2020. Punting any significant reductions until after 2020 means that the Dingell-Boucher plan falls grossly short of what is needed to forestall catastrophe:

Dingell-Boucher emissions pathway

In contrast, Europe is maintaining its commitment to unilateral reductions of 20 percent below 1990 levels by 2020.

REGULATORY STRUCTURE. In their letter to other members, Dingell and Boucher criticize the Supreme Court’s Massachusetts v. EPA decision that the EPA must regulate greenhouse gases, saying, “We believe that elected and accountable representatives in the Congress, not the Executive Branch, should properly design that regulatory program.” Their legislation would overturn the Supreme Court ruling by removing greenhouse gases from the Clean Air Act’s National Ambient Air Quality Standards regulations.

The draft provides a broad range of options for dealing with vehicle emissions standards, ranging from preempting the right of California and other states to provide additional protection from automotive pollution to allowing the EPA and the states to implement such protections. They also signal that they see state-level regulation of emissions as an economic threat, saying their actions “could be disruptive to interstate commerce and counterproductive to the goal of limiting national greenhouse gas emissions.” Their draft legislation would outlaw any state or regional cap and trade program.

MONEY. The Center for American Progress strongly supports the “polluter pays” principle for cap and trade programs to reduce global warming. The cost of pollution allowances should not be shifted to the taxpayer. Giving free permits to polluters would be a global warming bailout. The polluting industries are lobbying heavily to receive most if not all permits for free, particularly in initial years of the program. The European cap-and-trade system originally gave away permits, resulting in massive windfall profits for polluters. They are moving to a full auction of permits, like the new Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative cap-and-trade program that covers northeastern states.

The Dingell-Boucher draft does not take a position on how permits should be allocated initially, instead detailing four scenarios, three of which involve massive giveaways to covered industries. In every scenario, Dingell-Boucher would protect low-income consumers from increases in energy prices through tax breaks and rebates, and invest heavily in new technology deployment (e.g., renewables, advanced coal, advanced vehicles). Although their allocation scenarios are risible in detail, they do a good job of covering the competing priorities in moving to a low-carbon economy:
  1. Protect low-income consumers from energy costs
  2. Minimize compliance costs for covered polluters
  3. Invest in technology development and deployment
  4. Invest in complementary programs in efficiency and clean energy
  5. Support international efforts and adaptation
  6. Give rebates to middle- and upper-income consumers

Dingell and Boucher believe that low-income families must be protected, that industry should receive pollution cost protection and new technology support, and that all else is up for debate. Nearly two-thirds of their Democratic colleagues indicated last week a very different set of priorities, that focuses not on protecting polluters but on respecting scientific urgency, delivering economic equity, and capturing the energy opportunity.

Comments

Leave a response

  1. wwwe Fri, 07 Dec 2018 02:37:27 GMT
    nike air max shoes michael kors outlet jordan 6 birkin bag yeezy adidas nmd r1 air max coach outlet store michael kors outlet handbags adidas stan smith uk kyrie irving shoes adidas gazelle coach factory outlet michael kors outlet online cheap nfl jerseys china off white jordan 1 air max 2017 jordan retro moncler michael kors handbags golden goose slide yeezy fila shoes michael kors outlet supreme clothing kate spade outlet michael kors factory outlet ultra boost 3.0 replica rolex mbt shoes sale adidas yeezy kyrie 4 goyard bag sale jordan shoes air max 2018 adidas stan smith women ferragamo belt nike react flyknit lacoste polo shirts air jordan 11 mbt shoes online nike roshe air jordan shoes nike epic react flyknit kobe 9 curry 5 yeezy boost 350 v2 yeezy boost 350 red bottom shoes harden shoes balenciaga speed off white ultra boost longchamp handbags hermes belt custom baseball jerseys zx flux longchamp hyperdunks converse shoes nike cortez women jordan retro adidas tubular adidas shoes for women russell westbrook shoes adidas yeezy boost adidas ultra boost adidas tubular x nike air force fenty puma golden goose louboutin shoes michael kors factory outlet pure boost adidas yeezy yeezy 700 nike shox pg 1 links of london sale adidas outlet nike react irving shoes hermes belt chrome hearts online fitflops sale goyard handbags balenciaga sneakers off white jordan 1 adidas eqt yeezy boost 350 curry shoes pandora charms kevin durant shoes kobe basketball shoes hermes handbags hermes handbags tote bag yeezy boost chrome hearts outlet adidas ultra boost 3.0 jordan shoes nike flyknit off white clothing yeezy boost 350 nike air max lebron james shoes nike roshe one converse outlet nike huarache nike air max 2019 michael kors outlet online michael kors fila shoes nike air max louboutin shoes salvatore ferragamo belt golden goose sale kd 10 hermes birkin bag lacoste polo shirts lacoste polo yeezy shoes puma fenty off white shoes air jordan 6 chrome hearts outlet air max 2019 calvin klein underwear nike lebron 16 nike air max 2018 air max michael kors outlet nike flyknit trainer goyard tote vapormax air jordan 12 links of london nike air force 1 low kobe shoes cheap jordans kd 11 golden goose francy asics shoes air jordan lebron 13 iniki caterpillar boots yeezy shoes hermes belts golden goose mid star longchamp bape hoodie hermes bag hermes belts nike air max 2017 adidas ultra boost nike air force 1 high nike react moncler vans shoes jordan 11 adidas shoes online coach outlet stores golden goose yeezy shoes yeezy nike basketball shoes yeezy shoes yeezy 500 blush michael kors outlet yeezy shoes off white nike hermes birkin bape hoodie adidas pure boost off-white lebron 16 moncler jackets adidas stan smith cheap nfl jerseys tory burch handbags adidas gazelle sale red bottom shoes for women yeezy boost birkin bag michael kors outlet online adidas superstar coach outlet store moncler outlet hermes michael kors outlet store cheap jordan shoes michael kors outlet nike air vapormax goyard handbags golden goose starter michael kors outlet lebron 15 kyrie 3 nike shoes tory burch outlet adidas yeezy jordan 1 off white michael kors handbags yeezy boost longchamp bags calvin klein outlet jordans yeezy boost 350 v2 longchamp handbags nmd r1 reebok outlet hermes birkin yeezys goyard nike sneakers lebron 14 air max 270 yeezy boost 350 longchamps goyard wallet coach outlet golden goose sneakers fake rolex coach outlet online nike outlet lebron shoes jordan 4 tory burch chrome hearts nike lebron 15 james harden shoes kobe sneakers huaraches nike shox outlet balenciaga polo ralph lauren canada goose nba jerseys valentino golden goose sneakers goyard handbags adidas store lebron shoes lebron 16 shoes kobe 11 adidas iniki runner air jordans longchamp fila outlet kd shoes golden goose outlet balenciaga triple s kobe byrant shoes fila disruptor coach factory outlet michael kors purses yeezy boost 350 v2 balenciaga shoes nike air max chrome hearts moncler hogan outlet hermes birkin supreme clothing rolex replica adidas shoes for men bape clothing lebron 16 moncler jackets golden goose canada goose jacket cheap mlb jerseys off white hoodie nmd jordan shoes adidas tubular adidas yeezy golden goose superstar adidas yeezy outlet golden goose mlb jerseys jordan retro kobe shoes fila shoes michael kors outlet online adidas yeezy boost lacoste online shop crazy explosive paul george shoes adidas shoes valentino shoes stephen curry shoes balenciaga shoes lebron james shoes lacoste outlet yeezy shoes kd 11 lacoste polo longchamp handbags yeezy 500 yeezy 500 hermes handbags hogan outlet online yeezy boost 350 v2 ysl handbags yeezy boost 350 hermes handbags off-white adidas nmd adidas stan smith men gucci belt goyard outlet fila fila disruptor 2 coach outlet store foamposites adidas superstar shoes mbt shoes golden goose sneakers yeezy jordan 13 goyard bags yeezys off white hoodie yeezy sneakers adidas iniki yeezy boost 350 v2 coach outlet michael kors handbags retro jordans goyard online air max yeezy lacoste polo timberland shoes off white jordan 1 golden goose coach outlet jordans adidas nmd yeezys huarache shoes moncler sale vans outlet chrome hearts store nike cortez gucci belts timberland outlet curry 5 lebron 16 authentic jordans adidas nmd balenciaga sneakers kevin durant shoes michael kors outlet nike shox for women fila supreme hoodie cheap jordans golden goose jimmy choo golden goose sneakers longchamp bags fitflops sale clearance nike epic react flyknit kobe 9 michael kors handbags sale ferragamo belt kobe 11 golden goose shoes curry 4 ralph lauren uk curry 4 adidas stan smith huarache shoes cheap jordans hermes belt coach bags sale pureboost air max 90 michael kors nike polo cheapjordans balenciaga speed kobe byrant shoes nike air max 90 yeezy boost 350 nike huarache jordan shoes asics sneakers yeezy boost golden goose coach outlet handbags hermes outlet online adidas flux christian louboutin shoes adidas yeezy caterpillar shoes nike air force 1 yeezy boost 350 v2 pandora bracelet goyard handbags nike hyperdunk michael kors sale jordan 12 jordan retro 13 nhl jerseys rolex replica kd 11 shoes adidas eqt support adv fila online shop rolex replica watches michael kors cheap nba jerseys nmd jimmy choo shoes nike jordans nfl jerseys ferragamo sale kd shoes cheap basketball shoes jordan shoes goyard yeezy wave runner 700 kate spade handbags
Comments