Obama Starts Process to Grant California Waiver; Auto Industry Cries Foul 11

Posted by Wonk Room Mon, 26 Jan 2009 17:50:00 GMT

From the Wonk Room.

Today, President Obama took a step to reverse Bush-era intransigence on the fight against global warming, directing “federal regulators on Monday to move swiftly on an application by California and 13 other states to set strict limits on greenhouse gases from cars and trucks.” In 2002, California passed greenhouse gas standards for vehicle emissions, since adopted by 13 other states. However, they have been blocked since then by litigation from the automakers in concert with the Bush administration.

The auto lobby continues to fight this long-needed change. In an interview with National Public Radio, Charles Territo of the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers claimed the California standard would bring catastrophe:

At this difficult time, what we need is certainty and consistency, not confusion and chaos. And I think we’re all concerned that this would create chaos, not only for consumers, but also for dealers and for manufacturers.
The auto industry has long been able to handle California’s higher emissions standards for other pollutants. Jerry Brown, California’s attorney general, retorted that Detroit’s problems have come in large part because of its failure to innovate:
The irony here is the auto companies want a bailout, in many ways because they weren’t building the kind of cars that were compatible with today’s energy market – and at the same time, they want to keep going with their lawsuits, which have already cost millions and millions of dollars.

These auto industry lawsuits against the adoption of AB 1493 include:

Massachusetts

Massachusetts et al v EPA et al
Status: Industry lost in federal appeals and Supreme Court.

In 2003, the Environmental Protection Agency ruled it would not regulate transportation sector greenhouse gases. Massachusetts and 11 other states sued the EPA in the U.S. Court of Appeals. Auto industry trade groups argued in favor of the EPA’s inaction. The Court of Appeals ruled for the EPA in 2005. In 2006, the U.S. Supreme Court heard the appeal, and on April 2, 2007 ruled that the EPA had to begin the regulatory process for greenhouse gases. On July 11, 2008, the Bush administration grudgingly published draft regulations.

California

Central Valley Chrysler Jeep, et al v Goldstene et al (No. 08-17380)
Status: Industry lost in district court, filed federal appeal.

Filed in California district court in 2006 and stayed until the Supreme Court Mass v. EPA decision, the judge found against the plaintiffs in December 2007. The plaintiffs filed an appeal in the Ninth Circuit on October 30, 2008.

Vermont

Green Mountain Chrysler-Plymouth-Dodge v. Crombie (No. 07-4342, filed 10/5/2007, Second Circuit)
Status: Industry lost in district court, filed federal appeal.

On September 12, 2007, a federal judge in Vermont ruled that the state may impose its own greenhouse gas emission standards on automakers. Vermont Chrysler and Ford dealerships, with the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers, the Association of International Automobile Manufacturers, Chrysler, and General Motors appealed the decision to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals.

Rhode Island

Lincoln Dodge, Inc et al v. Sullivan (No. 06-00070, filed 2/13/20065, District of Rhode Island)
Status: In district court.

On November 25, the district court in Rhode Island dismissed the automakers from the lawsuit, holding that they are already suing in California and Vermont. The co-plaintiff auto dealers are maintaining the suit.

New Mexico

Zangara Dodge, Inc et al. v. Ron Curry et al. (No. 07-01305, filed 12/27/2007, in District of New Mexico)
Status: In district court.

New Mexico car dealers and the National Automobile Dealers Association sued to block the New Mexico Clean Car program in April 2008.

Maine

Status: State court denied stay.

The Kennebec County Superior court denied a request by the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers to stay Maine’s standards, and refused to send the matter back to the Maine Board of Environmental Protection (BEP) for reconsideration.

When asked by the Wonk Room how much his group is spending on these lawsuits, Territo said, “It’s not relevant how much money AAM has spent because there are so many other groups participating.”

Comments

Leave a response

  1. 44 mpg by March 2009 Tue, 27 Jan 2009 00:21:47 GMT

    This discussion raises an odd question about compliance with the California Waiver emissions and fueleconomy specs/standards.

    Which most closely satisfies the proposed California Emissions standards:

    A) US manufactured and specificationed vehicles?

    ... OR …

    B) GM, Ford, and Chrysler/Fiat’s European vehicles (E/U spec’ed) rated above 40 mpg(US) [about 48 mpg(Imperial)] combined cycle?

    Does anyone know?

    How about a best guess?

    It certainly would be really nice to know the real facts right now!

    If the Det3 EU vehicles are closer … why not temporary (say 24 months) WAIVE ALL import restrictions on new EU approved vehicles rated greater than 51 mpg(Imperial) combined cycle. This would open a previously untapped US market segment above 44 mpg(US), giving the Det3 the opportunity for immediate NEW POSITIVE CASHFLOW and the chance to increase domestic market share and subsequently, ultimately increasing domestic manufacturing output.

    The 24 month waiver immediately gives consumer choice/experience, IMMEDIATE NEW CASHFLOW for Det3, provides low cost/risk visibility to buyer preferences, opens the 44 to 63 mpg(US) combined average market sector, reduces oil imports/emissions, provides Det3 time to resolve emissions/safety issues in order to establish domestic manufacture/sale of “popular” configuration (including small displacement diesels).

    How is that for a “Quick Response, Self Funding, Low Cost, Low Risk Auto Industry/Economy Stimulus Strategy” (probable value $20 ~$120 BILLION).

  2. fatihin Tue, 16 Aug 2016 02:27:22 GMT
  3. fatihin Tue, 16 Aug 2016 02:27:53 GMT
  4. fatihin Mon, 22 Aug 2016 10:02:41 GMT

    Cuaca ekstrem ini diperkirakan akan berlangsung hingga Februari mendatang dan bukan hanya menimbulkan Konstruksi Baja fabrikasi

  5. fatihin Mon, 22 Aug 2016 10:03:08 GMT

    bencana alam tetapi juga membuat harga pangan melonjak. Besi Beton

  6. fatihin Sat, 27 Aug 2016 04:16:55 GMT
  7. fatihin Sat, 27 Aug 2016 04:17:19 GMT

    Anda bisa melihatnya untuk menjadikan konstruksi tangga baja konstruksi bangunan statis tertentu

  8. fatihin nurul Wed, 09 Nov 2016 03:16:51 GMT
  9. fatihin Sat, 26 Nov 2016 07:20:27 GMT
  10. wwwe Thu, 20 Sep 2018 04:42:02 GMT
    hermes belt adidas yeezy longchamp bags westbrook shoes lebron 15 shoes adidas nmd chrome hearts russell westbrook shoes adidas superstar kate spade outlet lebron james shoes jordan shoes pandora charms adidas yeezy adidas ultra boost polo ralph lauren adidas yeezy goyard bag sale fitflops sale yeezy boost 350 v2 nike zoom nike dunk low kobe basketball shoes golden goose sneakers jordan 4 curry shoes retro jordans lebron soldier 10 chrome hearts outlet hermes birkin bag pandora jewelry michael kors outlet coach outlet stores adidas pure boost michael kors sale rolex replica watches louboutin shoes chrome hearts online moncler jackets michael kors outlet handbags bape clothing michael kors factory outlet yeezy shoes yeezy boost 350 v2 jordan shoes tom ford sunglasses coach outlet nike air force yeezy sneakers supreme hoodie iniki russell westbrook shoes timberland shoes nike air max bape hoodie mbt shoes online yeezy 500 nike cortez women kate spade handbags yeezy boost 350 yeezy boost 350 nike air force yeezy boost 350 gucci belt mbt shoes yeezys adidas shoes basketball shoes adidas yeezy adidas tubular nike outlet lacoste online shop off-white golden goose starter tory burch cheap jordan shoes jordan retro longchamp handbags converse shoes jordan shoes converse outlet coach factory outlet goyard handbags 100% real jordans for cheap ysl handbags michael kors golden goose superstar adidas eqt support adv yeezy shoes yeezy 700 air max 90 coach outlet pureboost kobe 9 nike air max 2018 nike roshe kobe shoes nmd fitflops sale clearance hermes belts adidas yeezy boost golden goose sneakers golden goose slide stephen curry shoes michael kors nike air max pandora bracelet asics shoes calvin klein outlet adidas ultra boost curry 5 longchamp bags hermes balenciaga sneakers balenciaga shoes huarache shoes adidas yeezy boost tom ford glasses lacoste polo shirts moncler paul george shoes chrome hearts outlet adidas stan smith nike hyperdunk harden shoes nike cortez nike air max 2019 crazy explosive nike sneakers hogan outlet online coach outlet store cheap nfl jerseys chrome hearts store lebron 15 balenciaga speed yeezy shoes kobe basketball shoes adidas gazelle air jordan 12 off white jordan 1 goyard tote golden goose air max 2017 tom ford glasses yeezy boost 350 curry 4 nike huarache air max gucci belts tory burch handbags balenciaga triple s adidas iniki runner mens basketball shoes adidas stan smith uk irving shoes goyard handbags michael kors purses adidas shoes adidas eqt yeezy boost 350 v2 huarache shoes golden goose mid star nike hyperdunk air max 90 yeezy boost 350 lacoste polo nmd nfl jerseys yeezy shoes coach outlet cheap nba jerseys cheap jordans moncler jackets adidas gazelle sale fila shoes jordan shoes adidas iniki replica rolex links of london nike huarache real jordans for sale cheap adidas nmd longchamp christian louboutin nike air max 90 hermes birkin pg 1 cheap nfl jerseys china yeezy wave runner 700 curry 5 fenty puma michael kors outlet hogan outlet coach outlet store adidas flux air max 2018 yeezy shoes michael kors outlet huaraches hermes handbags hermes birkin kobe 9 nike hyperdunk 2017 longchamp handbags balenciaga sneakers adidas nmd nike polo balenciaga speed red bottom shoes for women mbt shoes sale jordan shoes off white jordan 1 michael kors outlet reebok outlet nike air force 1 air max 270 adidas store yeezy hermes bag michael kors jordan 1 off white tom ford sunglasses jordans pandora bracelet damian lillard shoes michael kors factory outlet lebron 13 timberland outlet christian louboutin shoes fila outlet adidas yeezy golden goose fila shoes pandora charms michael kors outlet adidas superstar cheap nhl jerseys nike shox outlet yeezy nike huarache nike air max 2017 d rose shoes air jordan shoes michael kors outlet adidas shoes for men off white clothing yeezy boost 350 v2 golden goose francy asics sneakers supreme clothing hermes belts moncler jackets nike flyknit trainer chrome hearts yeezy boost lacoste polo shirts derrick rose shoes nike flyknit hermes belt yeezy adidas tubular moncler nmd r1 caterpillar shoes kevin durant shoes jordan 11 vans store adidas stan smith women basketball shoes jordan 6 kobe shoes paul george shoes off-white kyrie irving shoes adidas stan smith golden goose golden goose sale moncler sale hermes handbags nike air vapormax goyard online adidas nmd hermes birkin vans shoes converse shoes salvatore ferragamo belt nike jordans nike roshe one nike shoes kayno kobe byrant shoes ferragamo belt hermes outlet online ultra boost asics gel kayano coach bags sale michael kors outlet online goyard handbags nike shox kevin durant shoes adidas ultra boost 3.0 ralph lauren uk nike basketball shoes zx flux nike lebron 11 yeezy yeezy boost yeezy nfl jerseys golden goose shoes foamposites yeezy boost 350 air jordan 6 pandora jewelry adidas shoes for women nike dunks michael kors handbags sale adidas tubular x adidas ultra boost adidas yeezy air jordan golden goose jordan retro nike air zoom nike epic react flyknit nhl jerseys vapormax goyard bags nike react pure boost michael kors handbags prada eyeglasses balenciaga shoes nike air max 90 balenciaga off white hoodie nba jerseys moncler outlet adidas superstar UK coach outlet handbags longchamp air max yeezy boost 350 hermes belt air jordans mlb jerseys kobe byrant shoes nike air max shoes vans outlet cheap mlb jerseys nike air zoom pegasus 32 moncler outlet balenciaga nike flyknit nmd r1 lebron 14 hermes handbags lebron shoes jordans yeezy boost nike air zoom structure 19 nike free run balenciaga sneakers calvin klein underwear jordan 12 michael kors outlet lebron soldier 11 lacoste polo kd 10 yeezy boost 350 v2 off white louboutin shoes balenciaga sneakers nike epic react flyknit adidas shoes online golden goose outlet coach outlet store michael kors outlet store jordan 13 nfl store rolex replica kyrie 3 caterpillar boots rolex replica golden goose cheap jordans converse outlet store adidas nmd r1 yeezy boost vibram fivefingers cheap jordans yeezy 500 hermes handbags tote bag air force ones michael kors handbags longchamp handbags cheapjordans nike react flyknit christian louboutin shoes nike air force 1 high kyrie 4 custom baseball jerseys off white jordan 1 john wall shoes air jordan 11 kobe 11 links of london nike react kobe 11 nike air max adidas stan smith men fake rolex golden goose goyard handbags ferragamo sale nike air force 1 michael kors outlet online michael kors tory burch outlet air max 2019 golden goose sneakers coach outlet online nike flyknit racer moncler vans shoes longchamp ultra boost 3.0 curry 4 michael kors outlet store off white hoodie michael kors handbags off white shoes adidas nmd nike air force 1 low yeezy shoes yeezy 500 blush goyard wallet nike shox for women jordan retro hyperdunks longchamp longchamps adidas eqt birkin bag lebron 15 coach factory outlet goyard nike huarache red bottom shoes kd shoes ferragamo belt kyrie 4 kobe sneakers goyard moncler jackets fila online shop james harden shoes lacoste outlet outlet golden goose dior sunglasses bape hoodie adidas outlet nike mercurial adidas eqt support adv yeezys birkin bag air max lacoste polo fila adidas ultra boost 3.0 prada sunglasses michael kors outlet longchamp bags longchamp puma fenty michael kors handbags nike lebron 15 yeezy jordan retro 13 links of london sale goyard outlet supreme clothing nike mercurial vapor off white nike yeezy shoes michael kors outlet online golden goose sneakers yeezy boost 350 v2
  11. wwwe Thu, 20 Sep 2018 04:42:04 GMT
    hermes belt adidas yeezy longchamp bags westbrook shoes lebron 15 shoes adidas nmd chrome hearts russell westbrook shoes adidas superstar kate spade outlet lebron james shoes jordan shoes pandora charms adidas yeezy adidas ultra boost polo ralph lauren adidas yeezy goyard bag sale fitflops sale yeezy boost 350 v2 nike zoom nike dunk low kobe basketball shoes golden goose sneakers jordan 4 curry shoes retro jordans lebron soldier 10 chrome hearts outlet hermes birkin bag pandora jewelry michael kors outlet coach outlet stores adidas pure boost michael kors sale rolex replica watches louboutin shoes chrome hearts online moncler jackets michael kors outlet handbags bape clothing michael kors factory outlet yeezy shoes yeezy boost 350 v2 jordan shoes tom ford sunglasses coach outlet nike air force yeezy sneakers supreme hoodie iniki russell westbrook shoes timberland shoes nike air max bape hoodie mbt shoes online yeezy 500 nike cortez women kate spade handbags yeezy boost 350 yeezy boost 350 nike air force yeezy boost 350 gucci belt mbt shoes yeezys adidas shoes basketball shoes adidas yeezy adidas tubular nike outlet lacoste online shop off-white golden goose starter tory burch cheap jordan shoes jordan retro longchamp handbags converse shoes jordan shoes converse outlet coach factory outlet goyard handbags 100% real jordans for cheap ysl handbags michael kors golden goose superstar adidas eqt support adv yeezy shoes yeezy 700 air max 90 coach outlet pureboost kobe 9 nike air max 2018 nike roshe kobe shoes nmd fitflops sale clearance hermes belts adidas yeezy boost golden goose sneakers golden goose slide stephen curry shoes michael kors nike air max pandora bracelet asics shoes calvin klein outlet adidas ultra boost curry 5 longchamp bags hermes balenciaga sneakers balenciaga shoes huarache shoes adidas yeezy boost tom ford glasses lacoste polo shirts moncler paul george shoes chrome hearts outlet adidas stan smith nike hyperdunk harden shoes nike cortez nike air max 2019 crazy explosive nike sneakers hogan outlet online coach outlet store cheap nfl jerseys chrome hearts store lebron 15 balenciaga speed yeezy shoes kobe basketball shoes adidas gazelle air jordan 12 off white jordan 1 goyard tote golden goose air max 2017 tom ford glasses yeezy boost 350 curry 4 nike huarache air max gucci belts tory burch handbags balenciaga triple s adidas iniki runner mens basketball shoes adidas stan smith uk irving shoes goyard handbags michael kors purses adidas shoes adidas eqt yeezy boost 350 v2 huarache shoes golden goose mid star nike hyperdunk air max 90 yeezy boost 350 lacoste polo nmd nfl jerseys yeezy shoes coach outlet cheap nba jerseys cheap jordans moncler jackets adidas gazelle sale fila shoes jordan shoes adidas iniki replica rolex links of london nike huarache real jordans for sale cheap adidas nmd longchamp christian louboutin nike air max 90 hermes birkin pg 1 cheap nfl jerseys china yeezy wave runner 700 curry 5 fenty puma michael kors outlet hogan outlet coach outlet store adidas flux air max 2018 yeezy shoes michael kors outlet huaraches hermes handbags hermes birkin kobe 9 nike hyperdunk 2017 longchamp handbags balenciaga sneakers adidas nmd nike polo balenciaga speed red bottom shoes for women mbt shoes sale jordan shoes off white jordan 1 michael kors outlet reebok outlet nike air force 1 air max 270 adidas store yeezy hermes bag michael kors jordan 1 off white tom ford sunglasses jordans pandora bracelet damian lillard shoes michael kors factory outlet lebron 13 timberland outlet christian louboutin shoes fila outlet adidas yeezy golden goose fila shoes pandora charms michael kors outlet adidas superstar cheap nhl jerseys nike shox outlet yeezy nike huarache nike air max 2017 d rose shoes air jordan shoes michael kors outlet adidas shoes for men off white clothing yeezy boost 350 v2 golden goose francy asics sneakers supreme clothing hermes belts moncler jackets nike flyknit trainer chrome hearts yeezy boost lacoste polo shirts derrick rose shoes nike flyknit hermes belt yeezy adidas tubular moncler nmd r1 caterpillar shoes kevin durant shoes jordan 11 vans store adidas stan smith women basketball shoes jordan 6 kobe shoes paul george shoes off-white kyrie irving shoes adidas stan smith golden goose golden goose sale moncler sale hermes handbags nike air vapormax goyard online adidas nmd hermes birkin vans shoes converse shoes salvatore ferragamo belt nike jordans nike roshe one nike shoes kayno kobe byrant shoes ferragamo belt hermes outlet online ultra boost asics gel kayano coach bags sale michael kors outlet online goyard handbags nike shox kevin durant shoes adidas ultra boost 3.0 ralph lauren uk nike basketball shoes zx flux nike lebron 11 yeezy yeezy boost yeezy nfl jerseys golden goose shoes foamposites yeezy boost 350 air jordan 6 pandora jewelry adidas shoes for women nike dunks michael kors handbags sale adidas tubular x adidas ultra boost adidas yeezy air jordan golden goose jordan retro nike air zoom nike epic react flyknit nhl jerseys vapormax goyard bags nike react pure boost michael kors handbags prada eyeglasses balenciaga shoes nike air max 90 balenciaga off white hoodie nba jerseys moncler outlet adidas superstar UK coach outlet handbags longchamp air max yeezy boost 350 hermes belt air jordans mlb jerseys kobe byrant shoes nike air max shoes vans outlet cheap mlb jerseys nike air zoom pegasus 32 moncler outlet balenciaga nike flyknit nmd r1 lebron 14 hermes handbags lebron shoes jordans yeezy boost nike air zoom structure 19 nike free run balenciaga sneakers calvin klein underwear jordan 12 michael kors outlet lebron soldier 11 lacoste polo kd 10 yeezy boost 350 v2 off white louboutin shoes balenciaga sneakers nike epic react flyknit adidas shoes online golden goose outlet coach outlet store michael kors outlet store jordan 13 nfl store rolex replica kyrie 3 caterpillar boots rolex replica golden goose cheap jordans converse outlet store adidas nmd r1 yeezy boost vibram fivefingers cheap jordans yeezy 500 hermes handbags tote bag air force ones michael kors handbags longchamp handbags cheapjordans nike react flyknit christian louboutin shoes nike air force 1 high kyrie 4 custom baseball jerseys off white jordan 1 john wall shoes air jordan 11 kobe 11 links of london nike react kobe 11 nike air max adidas stan smith men fake rolex golden goose goyard handbags ferragamo sale nike air force 1 michael kors outlet online michael kors tory burch outlet air max 2019 golden goose sneakers coach outlet online nike flyknit racer moncler vans shoes longchamp ultra boost 3.0 curry 4 michael kors outlet store off white hoodie michael kors handbags off white shoes adidas nmd nike air force 1 low yeezy shoes yeezy 500 blush goyard wallet nike shox for women jordan retro hyperdunks longchamp longchamps adidas eqt birkin bag lebron 15 coach factory outlet goyard nike huarache red bottom shoes kd shoes ferragamo belt kyrie 4 kobe sneakers goyard moncler jackets fila online shop james harden shoes lacoste outlet outlet golden goose dior sunglasses bape hoodie adidas outlet nike mercurial adidas eqt support adv yeezys birkin bag air max lacoste polo fila adidas ultra boost 3.0 prada sunglasses michael kors outlet longchamp bags longchamp puma fenty michael kors handbags nike lebron 15 yeezy jordan retro 13 links of london sale goyard outlet supreme clothing nike mercurial vapor off white nike yeezy shoes michael kors outlet online golden goose sneakers yeezy boost 350 v2
Comments