Senate Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee

Climate disclosure, focusing on measuring financial risks and opportunities 3

538 Dirksen
Wed, 31 Oct 2007 18:30:00 GMT

Committee page

Witnesses
  • Dr. Gary Yohe, Professor of Economics, Wesleyan University
  • Mr. Jeffery Smith, Partner in Charge of Environmental Practice, Cravath, Swaine, and Moore
  • Ms. Mindy Lubber, President, Ceres
  • Mr. Russell Read, Chief Investment Officer, California Public Employees’ Retirement System

Financial Week:

Senate Banking Committee takes up corporate disclosure of financial risk from climate change By Nicholas Rummell October 31, 2007

Several leading Democrats on the Senate Banking Committee say they want to push for greater disclosure from companies about the financial risk they face from climate change.

The move by Democrats is largely the by-product of a petition sent to the Securities and Exchange Commission last month. That petition requested that the SEC require companies to spell out material losses from climate change, such as the impact of new fuel regulations on automakers.

According to the petitioners, who include regulators in 11 states as well as institutional investors and advocacy groups, companies are currently required to delineate such risks under accounting rules, but they often fail to meet those requirements because of poor regulatory guidance. Business groups often argue that such information is confidential.

A Banking Committee hearing on the topic late last month was sparsely attended, by only Democratic members, but it shows congressional interest in the financial risks argument. Sen. Robert Casey (D-Pa.) said he thinks the federal government should act to “chart a new course” for stopping climate change and improving financial returns for companies, which he called “two ends of a problem.”

A bill being marked up in another Senate committee reportedly would require new SEC regulations to require public companies to inform shareholders about financial disclosure of and economic impact of global warming on the company. The bill, sponsored by Sens. Joseph Lieberman (I-Conn.) and John Warner (R-Va.), places caps on carbon emissions.

Current climate change disclosures are inconsistent, which makes it difficult for investors to compare one company’s disclosure with others, said Russell Read, chief investment officer at the $259 billion California Public Employees’ Retirement System. Mr. Read said the SEC currently can require greater disclosure, but that it probably needs “prodding” by Congress to do so.

Some feel additional disclosure would lead to more inconsistent filings. Gary Yohe, an economics professor at Wesleyan University, said that, depending on whether a company evaluates risk to customers or the entire social cost of carbon use, “you get a wide range of numbers.”

Such guidance should focus only on companies that would be significantly impacted by climate change. “It would be a mistake for everyone to say something,” said Jeffrey Smith, lead partner in the environmental practice at law firm Cravath Swaine & Moore. Flooding the market with insignificant disclosure would hurt investors, he said, noting that companies should be “poised” to address useful information in filings. “Fake numbers are bad.”

Mindy Lubber, president of environmental advocacy group Ceres, testified that insurers face quantifiable financial risks from prolonged droughts and wildfires, energy companies face climate-change litigation and other companies face risk from greenhouse gas regulations. She cited recent investment bank research reports as evidence that Wall Street is starting to pay attention to the costs attributed to climate change.

Ms. Lubber said the petitioners don’t want “an onerous new disclosure regime,” but rather to tighten up current accounting standards on physical risks that can be evaluated, such as litigation or losses due to hurricanes. Petitioners in recent years have repeatedly asked the SEC to issue guidance, but the SEC has ignored such requests, she said.

The clamor for financial disclosure related to climate change has also made for strange bedfellows. Steven Milloy and Thomas Borelli, climate change skeptics and mutual fund managing partners, filed a petition for rule-making with the SEC earlier this month. They want companies to have to disclose the business risks of laws and regulations that address global warming.

The two activists, critical of the global warming movement and attempts at regulation, found that of 21 corporate members of the U.S. Climate Action Partnership, only five disclosed that global warming regulation is a business risk. USCAP is a group of 33 companies and environmental groups that calls for significant reductions in greenhouse gases. “USCAP members,” Messrs. Milloy and Borelli wrote in their petition, “are keeping shareholders in the dark.”

Case in point, the two say, is the impact on General Electric’s labor force of the proposed shift to compact fluorescent light bulbs from incandescent bulbs. GE manufactures the environmentally friendly compact bulbs in China, which has caused friction with the company’s U.S. employees. The petition also targets PepsiCo, Du Pont and Caterpillar—also members of USCAP—for not disclosing financial risks adequately, as well as Wal-Mart, which is not a member.

“Global warming regulation represents a serious risk to publicly owned corporations, yet this threat to corporate earnings and shareholder value is not being disclosed to shareholders,” the petition stated.

According to Ms. Lubber and supporters, companies actually could reap benefits by addressing climate change. One analysis cited by Ms. Lubber found that U.S. electric power companies that have not prepared for the future cost of carbon regulations could see losses in earnings of up to 17%. Conversely, the same analysis found that companies with less polluting fuel mixes could see earnings increase by as much as 15%, she said.

The SEC has not issued a response on either petition and is not required to do so, though staffers may review them.

Environmental proxy proposals seeking more data on financial risk from global warming have come into vogue (see “Green Proxies to Be Red Hot This Season,” FW, Oct. 29). Last year, environmental activist shareholders filed a record-breaking number of green proposals; even more are planned for the 2008 season.

Trackbacks

This event's trackback address

Comments

Leave a response

  1. jiuer7845 Thu, 19 Jul 2018 04:01:10 GMT
  2. cai123 Wed, 17 Oct 2018 01:10:11 GMT
    cai123 10.17 canada goose outlet store canada goose birkenstock shoes coach outlet store online salvatore ferragamo outlet salomon outlet orioles jerseys canada goose outlet online discount oakley sunglasses tory burch handbags uggs outlet store coach outlet online pandora charms pandora charms sale clearance coach factorty outlet online kate spade outlet online pandora charms outlet ysl handbags nike cortez classic uggs outlet store timberland shoes astros jerseys coach outlet online pandora outlet store red bottom heels michael kors outlet store yeezy boost 350 michael kors canada adidas stan smith uggs outlet coach outlet online michael kors outlet canada michael kors outlet online timberland shoes jimmy choo shoes true religion jeans coach factory outlet ronaldo jerseys ralph lauren uk michael kors outlet clearance coach outlet online canada goose coats ugg boots outlet ysl outlet oakley sunglasses outlet supreme shirts adidas superstar shoes moncler outlet reebok outlet adidas originals coach factory outlet online cheap oakley sunglasses coach outlet store online pandora jewelry outlet fake rolex fitflops sale gucci outlet store canada goose coats birkenstock shoes outlet ray bans adidas outlet coach outlet online michael kors outlet online coach outlet online louboutin outlet nike huarache shoes cheap jordans birkenstock outlet store north face outlet store adidas nmd r1 tory burch outlet store pandora charms sale clearance adidas outlet store nike tessen kate spade outlet online coach factorty outlet store coach outlet online nike shoes pandora charms outlet ugg outlet cheap jordan shoes louis vuitton outlet online ugg boots outlet adidas sneakers michael kors toms outlet online uggs outlet coach factory outlet air max yeezy shoes converse outlet ralph lauren sale christian louboutin shoes coach outlet store online coach outlet online pandora jewelry michael kors outlet clearance ugg outlet online coach outlet online ugg boots pandora charms sale coach outlet store online clearance oakley sunglasses wholesale polo ralph lauren outlet online white sox jerseys pandora outlet cheap oakley sunglasses coach factory outlet online birkin handbags pandora jewelry outlet coach outlet canada indians jerseys birkenstock outlet birkenstock outlet store fitflops sale jimmy choo cheap ray ban sunglasses louis vuitton outlet store moncler coats timberland outlet toms shoes nfl jerseys birkenstock sandals nike zoom cheap ray ban sunglasses kate spade bags coach factory outlet online supreme shirts philipp plein ralph lauren outlet online polo ralph lauren pandora jewelry pg 2 shoes coach outlet timberland boots ugg outlet store columbia shoes uggs outlet nike outlet store gucci outlet online cheap jordans for sale louboutin outlet coach factorty outlet store nike shoes outlet tiffany and co jewelry coach outlet online uggs outlet coach outlet online nike outlet store lebron james shoes air max 1 canada goose coach factory outlet online ralph lauren sale coach outlet online hermes bag louboutin shoes air more uptempo longchamp outlet moncler outlet moncler coats fitflop sandals adidas yeezy shoes salvatore ferragamo christian louboutin shoes kate spade purses coach factory outlet online birkenstock sale pandora sale clearance kate spade outlet coach factory outlet online pandora charms sale clearance prada shoes louis vuitton outlet online air max outlet new balance outlet coach factory outlet online nike dunks ugg outlet longchamp uggs outlet kate spade outlet online canada goose christian louboutin shoes kate spade handbags marlins jerseys ugg outlet store canadian goose ray ban glasses kate spade outlet online air max canada goose coach outlet store tory burch outlet online kate spade handbags coach outlet online ugg outlet nike air presto adidas outlet online birkenstock uk nike free 5.0 pandora jewelry reds jerseys kate spade handbag ralph lauren sale clearance uk dr martens boots city royals jerseys ugg boots louis vuitton outlet coach canada kate spade handbags adidas outlet store cheap oakley sunglasses rolex replica watches canada goose timberland boots outlet swarovski crystal adidas nmd runner coach outlet online air max shoes coach outlet store online ugg boots pandora canada canada goose jackets birkenstock outlet nmd adidas columbia outlet coach factory outlet online burberry outlet store mont blanc pens fitflop sandals michael kors swarovski outlet coach outlet online canada goose outlet store uggs on sale moncler outlet store kobe shoes ecco outlet pandora charms outlet kate spade outlet fitflops sale clearance brewers jerseys longchamp outlet rolex replica watches for sale ralph lauren adidas nmd r1 pandora jewelry store coach outlet store online mets jerseys adidas shoes michael kors outlet online mont blanc pen diamondbacks jerseys hermes bags cheap air jordans underarmour outlet polo ralph lauren outlet pandora charms moncler outlet ecco shoes adidas shoes coach outlet pandora jewelry canada goose jackets nike zoom shoes ugg outlet store michael kors handbags polo outlet online louis vuitton factory outlet fred perry polo shirts adidas yeezy boost louis vuitton handbags coach factory outlet pirates jerseys moncler outlet online kate spade handbags ugg boots nike air max 2018 michael kors outlet salvatore ferragamo shoes ugg outlet store cartier watches kyrie 4 asics outlet nike sneakers ralph lauren outlet online adidas superstars canada goose outlet store canada goose parka nike outlet online mariners jerseys jordan shoes nike shoes pandora charms outlet nike outlet store kate spade outlet online cheap jordan shoes michael kors outlet online kate spade outlet online pandora charms sale discount oakley sunglasses vans outlet kate spade outlet online kate spade outlet online nike air max 2018 coach bags coach factory outlet coach factory outlet online lacoste polo shirts coach factory outlet canada goose outlet ralph lauren uk michael kors outlet clearance nike air max 97 canada goose outlet dr martens nike air max 97 michael kors outlet store air max shoes nike sneakers nike free 3.0 ralph lauren uk basketball shoes ugg outlet store canada goose nike react shoes coach factory outlet online hermes outlet ralph lauren angels jerseys ugg outlet online jordan shoes moncler outlet store uggs outlet pandora jewelry red bottom yeezy boost 350 moncler outlet store canada goose jackets new balance outlet store tory burch outlet online ugg outlet red bottoms adidas outlet online rockies jerseys burberry outlet mulberry uk michael kors outlet store retro 11 air max 87 coach outlet canada christian louboutin shoes supra for sale fitflop shoes air max 95 cheap nfl jerseys wholesale canada goose coats pandora charms outlet uggs outlet moncler outlet online birkenstock outlet online ugg boots nike running shoes jordan shoes for sale canada goose outlet store asics outlet store michael kors handbags ecco outlet true religion outlet store supreme uk philipp plein outlet nike cortez classic michael kors canada pandora charms outlet canada goose sale pandora charms polo ralph lauren outlet online polo ralph lauren outlet online ugg outlet nike air max 2019 louis vuitton factory outlet pandora outlet cheap jordans kate spade handbags hermes bags cheap jordan shoes fitflop sandals cheap air max ugg boots outlet nfl jerseys coach factory outlet online michael kors outlet clearance michael kors outlet clearance cheap air jordans jordans adidas nmd r1 polo ralph lauren outlet ugg outlet coach outlet online air max 90 ugg boots louboutin shoes pandora jewelry tiffany and co outlet ugg outlet online coach outlet store online yeezy shoes converse all star fitflops uk fitflop uk cheap jordans cheap ray ban sunglasses nike outlet store online nike shox shoes ugg canada christian louboutin shoes timberland outlet jimmy choo outlet michael kors outlet online ugg outlet oakley sunglasses outlet fred perry outlet canada goose outlet padres jerseys canada goose outlet store vans outlet store yeezy boost 350 prada outlet online cheap oakley sunglasses twins jerseys ralph lauren uk supra for sale michael kors outlet store rangers jersey michael kors outlet valentino outlet michael kors outlet store coach factory outlet uggs outlet ralph lauren outlet online kate spade outlet online michael kors outlet store adidas outlet online canadian goose jacket michael kors bags dodgers jerseys cheap jordan shoes devil rays jerseys mlb jerseys cheap yeezy shoes north face jackets yeezy boost adidas outlet store kate spade handbags canada goose outlet kate spade outlet store pandora charms sale kate spade bags air more money moncler ugg shoes ralph lauren sale clearance uk moncler outlet online coach canada outlet uggs outlet online christian louboutin sale cheap air jordans ugg canada adidas ultra boost skechers outlet pandora rings fendi handbags gucci outlet online coach factorty outlet online coach outlet online kate spade outlet kobe shoes canada goose jacket canada goose outlet cheap nike shoes ugg outlet online coach outlet canada nike huarache shoes rolex replica watches michael kors outlet online louis vuitton outlet athletics jerseys fitflops sale toms outlet store nike outlet nike air max zero ugg outlet online timberland outlet durant shoes air jordan shoes coach factory outlet air jordans canada goose jackets coach outlet canada moncler outlet online ugg boots polo ralph lauren outlet air jordan retro cheap jordan shoes kate spade purses blue jays jerseys ecco outlet dr martens boots timberland shoes converse shoes ralph lauren outlet online christian louboutin sale longchamp outlet online adidas yeezy adidas yeezy boost 350 adidas store supreme clothing coach outlet online mlb jerseys wholesale pandora charms nike outlet coach outlet store braves jerseys adidas campus shoes coach factory outlet online ecco shoes for women mulberry outlet uk nike outlet online moncler coats cheap jordans free shipping nike air max 90 ugg outlet store discount oakley sunglasses moncler jackets coach factory outlet online dansko shoes pandora jewelry outlet tiffany outlet cheap jordan shoes coach factory outlet online cai123 10.17
  3. qqq Thu, 16 May 2019 09:26:05 GMT
    cheap jordans free shipping prada outlet david yurman bracelet louboutin outlet coach outlet nike air max outlet adidas shoes jimmy choo fitflops outlet adidas outlet nike air max pas cher true religion jeans jordan 4 air max 2017 fivefingers shoes kate spade outlet pandora outlet cheap jordan shoes ralph lauren polo factory outlet moncler doudoune pas cher uggs italia fitflops sale nike air max david yurman coach outlet louis vuitton outlet prada sunglasses michael kors outlet store polo outlet new england patriots jerseys discount oakley sunglasses coach outlet canada goose outlet ultra boost dolce & gabbana sunglasses pandora charms ed hardy outlet coach outlet persol sunglasses coach outlet coach outlet ultra boost jordan shoes pandora jewelry outlet uggs christian louboutin outlet coach canada pandora jewelry jordans vans shoes celine handbags uggs kate spade outlet online vans shoes colts jersey nike air max 2015 匡威英国官网 ugg outlet coach outlet online michael kors outlet coach outlet north face gucci outlet ed hardy clothing minnesota twins jerseys snapback hats coach factory outlet rolex watches outlet christian louboutin shoes coach outlet true religion jeans outlet miu miu gucci outlet ed hardy clothing mac cosmetics denver broncos jerseys pandora charms louis vuitton outlet coach outlet store true religion outlet canada goose ralph lauren outlet store jordan retro pandora jewelry kate spade outlet pandora charms kate spade ralph lauren outlet nike factory outlet true religion outlet store cheap nhl jerseys coach outlet mcm outlet ugg canada detroit lions jerseys toms outlet christian louboutin qqq
Comments